The Varginha UFO

[John J.]

One of the things mentioned in the above video is that back then Globo showed this 1994 film. However, that was only on "Intercine", precisely on June 4, 1996, at 11 pm. "ROSWELL" has a scene which I'll explain what it's all about:

- In a key flashback sequence tied to the crash site investigation and the mystery of the recovered material, there is a demonstration of the so-called "memory metal" or "memory foil" - a piece of debris from the alleged alien craft. A character (often depicted as Marcel himself or someone showing it to a younger person, such as his son in some recollections, though the film adapts real witness accounts) takes a flat, rectangular piece of metallic-looking material (described as resembling aluminum foil but clearly not ordinary). The person crumples or folds the piece tightly, squeezing/compressing it in their hand.

A film drama about Roswell "...that adapts real witness accounts" (i.e., makes things up for dramatic effect) isn't evidence of anything, except that the story can be exploited commercially.

The Corona/ Roswell material was from a project Mogul balloon.
Its description as "a flying disc" originates from a press release by 1st Lt. William Haut, public information officer of the 809 Bomb Group.
So much for the military always covering up anything to do with UFOs (though the Corona/ Roswell balloon doesn't seem to have generated any UFO -flying object- reports).
The "memory foil" was probably a metallized plastic, a forerunner of boPET/ Mylar.

Brazel told the Record that the debris consisted of rubber strips, "tinfoil, paper, tape, and sticks."
...When interviewed in Fort Worth, Texas, Jesse Marcel described the wreckage as "parts of the weather device" composed of "tinfoil and broken wooden beams".

Pictures/ quote from Wikipedia, "Roswell incident" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roswell_incident

Edited to add: There was a cover-up, of course; though described by the USAAF as a weather balloon it was soon realised that it was a Mogul balloon, the public were not told this for many years. But it was still a balloon.

 

[BoulderRiver]

@Perene
Here's the google sheet with all the inconsistencies in Carlos de Souza story over the years.


Source: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Vfe6T2hgEt0sT8sqYMDlvGHYx3sTdz5SEpBPMFSJp7E/edit?gid=388387704#gid=388387704


It's also important to not that nobody in a 3km radius around the Maiolini farm noticed anything out of the ordinary, ever.
I was there in 2002. The region was already filled with houses, bars, a church, etc. It is literally impossible that nobody The crash, the Debris, the military operation.

 

[NorCal Dave]

SThe hypothesis that a secret revolutionary form of aircraft was developed, capable of accommodating four human-scale passengers, and it was decided to test fly it, over a heavily-populated area, with the malformed results of an equally secret primate experiment as passengers, makes no sense.
Developing a revolutionary aircraft only to use it to do some primate research, or to scare some random people in Brazil, isn't credible.
As with some of the sillier "explanations" of e.g. Roswell (bio-engineered Soviet "crew") there is no evidence, and both the hypothetical creatures and the hypothetical craft are wildly implausible.

You beat me to it. That was some wild-ass speculation going on with genetically modified apes flying around in cigar shaped UFOs, crashing in a farmers field, then one of them wondering over to town where it's mistaken for the Devil, then getting captured, then being taken to a regular public hospital and finally flown out of Brazil on a USAF flight. Kinda makes the MiBs look quaint.

As you mentioned, it's as fringe as Annie Jacobson's Nazi/Soviet genetically engineered munchkins. Like the claim she repeats, there is zero evidence for any of this. Of course, in this case that seems to mean it's factual and has been covered-up.

 

[Perene]

Can you relate how he knows "everything had to be a LIE" as opposed to "everything got increasingly far from reality as people's memories became 'tainted,' while they thought they were still honestly reporting what they think they remember?"

I am not sure if there may be a language issue at play here -- somebody can make a statement that is totally, 100% but not be lying if they believe what they are saying. "Lying" describes telling a story that you KNOW is not true. With that in mind, is your contention that people were knowingly telling untrue stories? If so, how do you know this was intentional on their part, how do you know they are not just honestly wrong?

I didn't explain that bit correctly, the "everything had to be a lie" was not what I meant (that everyone gathered and combined to tell fake stories). I was trying to say is that Ubirajara Rodrigues was at first convinced there was something worth pursuing in the Varginha case, then he became frustrated with the inconsistencies and no longer believes it amounted to something "extraordinary".

I found an article written in portuguese which mentions Carlos de Souza and the "metallic material with "shape memory", too. It's worth translating and posting for this thread, it really helps to further explain what I told before about the likelihood that someone (like Carlos) is lying (and if said person is doing for one bit of their story, it gets harder to believe the rest).

It's from the magazine "Questão de Ciência". I'm posting the full translation: (CLICK HERE). The original source (with hyperlinks) can be found here, too.

 

[John J.]

I found an article written in portuguese which mentions Carlos de Souza and the "metallic material with "shape memory", too.

Ah, I think I misunderstood a point you made in an earlier post (# 198).
Is it right to say you don't think Carlos de Souza is telling the truth? The "Fantasies and Contradictions of the Varginha Case" article you linked to implies this (and I might agree).

"Metallic material with 'shape memory'" was already an established part of UFO lore, associated with Roswell as you pointed out.
Repeating a trope apparently borrowed from an earlier UFO story, which has been thoroughly debunked, doesn't add credibility.
It just makes it look like the claimant was familiar with earlier UFO claims to a much greater extent than the average person.

If de Souza followed the UFO down in his microlite, and found a military presence already there (30-40 men, two trucks, an ambulance and a helicopter) then the crashing of a UFO must have been anticipated. This seems highly unlikely, unless the Brazilian military routinely monitor and translate the communications of alien craft, or can bring down UFOs at will, to the degree that they can determine where it will land.

A group of 30-40 men, two trucks, an ambulance and a helicopter seems to be a rather lacklustre response to an expected UFO crash.
It wouldn't be a particularly impressive response to a light aircraft crash; supposing there were more than one or two casualties, or there was a fire? Why no fire tenders? What if ET has more firepower than 30-40 men with smallarms in two trucks, and doesn't want to go to a provincial hospital?

If de Souza's later claim of the military arriving 10-15 minutes later is correct, it's still a very rapid response. Maybe there was a military base nearby (within a very few miles/ km), someone sighted what was believed to be an aircraft in trouble and (e.g.) an infantry platoon and a military ambulance were sent to assist.
But on realising (or at least suspecting) the nature of the incident, it would seem sensible to establish a perimeter and await more specialised assets. Collecting debris could interfere with a forensic crash investigation, and what about possible toxic or radiological hazards? The soldiers would probably have radio contact with their superiors (certainly if a helicopter was present as part of the team).
If the troops supposedly present were a cobbled-together contingency response to a suspected aircraft crash (and they'd be much better than nothing), you'd think that they, and their immediate bosses, would understand that a crashed extraterrestrial spaceship was beyond their paygrades or competencies.

 

[JMartJr]

I didn't explain that bit correctly, ...

Ahh, thank you, I believe that I understand your point better now.

 

[Gaspa]

...the moronic explanations that were given by the military (as far as I know, the "Mudinho" was one of the reasons given by them).

Judging our reality by our current metrics/understanding (including the laws of physics) doesn't mean we automatically close our minds to the possibility of something beyond our limited imagination. By rejecting 100% the possibility of being wrong (because the situation does not fit what WE know) or something shady has happened, we are not being smart.

Funny how the most likely explanation: that the girls saw a person that matches a lot of their description and lives nearby, but got scared for some reason; is "moronic", while it is "not smart" to reject the possibility of it being something beyond our current understanding of the laws of physics. Just hilarious.

How you expect anyone to take you seriously while writing these two things just one paragraph apart from each other is beyond me.

It was beginning to pour rain, they were taking a shortcut on an unkempt lot, so probably running, and saw someone crouched in the middle of the bushes by the wall and got scared. By their own recollection from on the first time they were interviewed for Fantástico, they said they didn't stop to look at the "thing" for long, they turned away in an instant and skedaddled. By the time they reached home, that sighting had become "the devil". And the devil has horns and all sorts of strange features, so that was attached to the memory. It just makes sense.

Then Ubirajara finds them and helpfully explains to them that they had encountered what experts such as himself label "aliens", and memories get further shaped from his descriptions of greys and whatnot. Horns become bumps in their memories, and so on. It's human psychology 101.