MH17 Evidence Video Time Stamped Before Crash

Status
Not open for further replies.

Libertarian

Banned
Banned
Debunked here:
https://www.metabunk.org/threads/de...ore-the-crash-and-other-timeline-issues.3988/

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The basis for this metabunk is the video featured in this Zero Hedge article:

There are several issues highlighted in the article, listed for metabunking as follows:
English version:
Russian version:


The article goes on to compare this video to a prior June 5 video produced also by the Ukrainian government and highlights the near identical production quality and placement of captions, layout of dubbing. Zero Hedge implies that the second two videos, like the June 5 one, were produced and uploaded by the new Ukraine government.

Apart from speculation that the server may have had an incorrect date set, has there been any further exploration of this video? Because a plausible alternative to the notion that the computer that created the video had an incorrect date is the notion that the computer had a correct date. And if it did that would be troublesome.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Pete Tar

Senior Member.
The fact it was uploaded by the Ukrainian government was never an issue was it? They were the ones who intercepted the audio and uploaded it, so what's the issue it has the same format as previous ones?

Timestamps are wrong all the time.
 

Pete Tar

Senior Member.
Well there's a demonstration of how timestamps are not indicative of when a video was uploaded here...
http://www.militaryphotos.net/forum...hread&p=7284980&viewfull=1#post7284980 <br />

Here's a post showing Obama made a speech about the crash before it happened.
http://www.militaryphotos.net/forum...thurt-thread&p=7285000&viewfull=1#post7285000

Do you have any evidence the video was created and uploaded before the incident took place?
Is that really what someone intending to frame someone would do, present the incriminating evidence before the crime has happened?
 

Libertarian

Banned
Banned
Do you have any evidence the video was created and uploaded before the incident took place?
Is that really what someone intending to frame someone would do, present the incriminating evidence before the crime has happened?

There is evidence in the OP that this video was created before the incident.

This is conjecture, but if it was created in advance, perhaps it was done in preparation such that it could be uploaded after the incident to assist in the subsequent investigation.

You haven't refuted the OP with any evidence.
 
Last edited:

David Coulter

Senior Member.
I tend to dismiss sources that are loaded with hyperbole:

The fact that the two cited youtubes had similar production value is not a smoking gun since they both came out of the Ukrainian security authorities.
 

Libertarian

Banned
Banned
If you dismiss hyperbole you must dismiss pretty much all news :)

Really though, do you have any proof upon which to base a dismissal of the evidence in the OP?
 

Pete Tar

Senior Member.
Why are you ignoring that timestamps of uploads to youtube are demonstrably wrong all the time? Isn't that evidence that refutes the claim?
How about you do an experiment - record a video of something that can serve as an objective time reference, (a news broadcast?), upload and compare the youtube timestamp with the time you know you made it.
It should be probably be done in a few different timezones from where the youtube servers are located to be thorough.
 

David Coulter

Senior Member.
You haven't refuted the OP with any evidence.

There is no way to prove a timestamp is incorrect (proving a negative problem). However, incorrect time settings on computers occur very frequently - probably more so within security organizations that are likely disconnected from the Internet and time servers. I would also expect that a national security apparatus that was perpetrating a "false flag" would get the time stamps correct.

The dilemma Putin finds himself in is that there are pictures and videos of the BUK's and there are, no doubt, witnesses loyal to Ukraine that saw the launch and crash. In addition, the separatists are restricting access to the area to international investigators - why do that if an investigation would prove it was shot down by Ukraine? More likely to allow time for the wreckage to be sanitized and limit access to witnesses.
 

David

Member
I don't know if this is mentioned in other threads, but I found an article about how youtube assigns dates to videos.

http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/20...es-russians-cite-false-claim-on-syria-videos/
 

TEEJ

Senior Member.
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
M Claim: Robert Parry: Australian 60 Minutes fudged evidence to pin blame on Russia Flight MH17 21
TEEJ MH17: Evidence a Missile was Used. Shrapnel, etc. Flight MH17 448
S Claim: Russian radar would have picked up MH17 missile Flight MH17 15
tadaaa MH17 Documentary from the BBC Flight MH17 81
U MH17 Missile/Plane Intersection Simulation Flight MH17 23
Mick West Almaz-Antey's Live BUK explosion tests Flight MH17 141
Bruce Lansberg Dutch Safety Board publish reports on MH17 crash, Tuesday Oct 13 Flight MH17 14
MikeC Dutch release draft report to involved parties Flight MH17 0
Herman Aven Confirmed Claim: disputed satelite imagery showing "changes in vegetation" Flight MH17 14
william wiley Does Damage to MH17 indicate or exclude a Particular Buk Launch Location? Flight MH17 662
Bruce Lansberg Claim: Jeroen Akkermans: Framents prove MH17 was shot down by a Russian made BUK Flight MH17 34
Bruce Lansberg Dutch Government discloses 245 official documents Flight MH17 0
M Debunked: this photo shows a Ukraine Mig-29 shot down MH17 Flight MH17 66
M Possible Shrapnel in MH17 Wreckage? Flight MH17 26
Bruce Lansberg Main prosecuter Westerbeke says metal particles have been found in the victims bodies and luggage Flight MH17 10
M Claim: Malaysian experts were shot at by Ukraine SU-25 and by GRAD Flight MH17 10
M Claim: MH17 was shot down by separatists using BUK stolen from Ukraine army Flight MH17 32
M What part of forward fuselage is this ? Flight MH17 1
R MH 370 Leroy Alexander? Flight MH17 1
M Solved: MH17: is this part of a missile? [Concrete Grinding Pads] Flight MH17 13
Ezswo Debunked: MH17 - 10 Previous Flightpaths Different From 17-7 Flight MH17 27
KAT MH17 - developments after a month - Aug 17 Flight MH17 4
Franckly Debunked: MH17 Air to air missile Assumption ? [Unrelated 35° angle] Flight MH17 25
Juha MH17 Hypotheses Flight MH17 159
WeeBee MH17: Pinpointing the precise location of the missile impact point Flight MH17 53
Jason Debunked: MH17: Supposed satellite video of missile launch [Fake] Flight MH17 14
Mick West Debunked: "Official Photoshopping" of MH17 photo [Window cover physically removed] Flight MH17 7
Brian Griffin Explained: MH17: Why Are There Expired "Pristine" Passports in the Wreckage? [Visa in Old Passport] Flight MH17 12
Mick West MH17: Video of flight activity before and after the crash Flight MH17 32
Josh Heuer MH17: Russia Claims Ukranian military plane flying nearby before incident Flight MH17 121
Mick West Debunked: MH17 Video Timestamped before the crash, and other timeline issues Flight MH17 8
Mick West Flight MH17 News Flight MH17 79
Gridlock Why was MH17 Flying Over The Conflict Region? Flight MH17 102
Leifer MH17.....claiming responsibility ? Flight MH17 19
C MH17 Malaysian 777 Carrying 295 People Shot Down Over Ukraine Flight MH17 410
Joe Hill Beirut Explosion -- Evidence It Wasn't Just A Surface Explosion Current Events 21
Mick West Debunked: Pentagon has Evidence of "Off-World Vehicles Not Made on this Earth" UFO Videos and Reports from the US Navy 14
C My girlfriend,Jungian Personality Theory and the Rabbit Hole (Dealing with Relationships) Escaping The Rabbit Hole 1
R "Breakthrough": U.S. Attorney Agrees to Present Evidence of WTC Demolition to Federal Grand Jury. 9/11 153
M How to Evaluate Specious Evidence (Like "Bubbles" in Space) Practical Debunking 6
Mick West Explained: Unburned trees next to burned down structures as evidence of secret "energy weapons" Wildfires 120
Everett Anderson Standard Atmospheric Refraction: Empirical Evidence and Derivation Flat Earth 18
deirdre J.Marvin Herndon tries to pass off Bird Poop as evidence of "chemtrail" spraying Contrails and Chemtrails 24
MikeC Claim: New Zealand quakes man made...... Conspiracy Theories 4
Bill Statler "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence": practical problems using this argument Practical Debunking 3
Mick West When Absence of Evidence is Evidence of Absence in Conspiracy Theories Practical Debunking 35
Jonathan Evans Gyroscopes as Evidence for a Spherical and Rotating Earth Flat Earth 4
Inti Claims that compass “symbols” are evidence of Masonic involvement Conspiracy Theories 8
Michael Mitchell Claim: Evidence for use of "Breaching Round" at Sandy Hook Sandy Hook 23
Mackdog Justice Scalia death: No autopsy as evidence of conspiracy Conspiracy Theories 15
Related Articles


















































Related Articles

Top