Debunking needed – anomalous mp3 recording distortion

Thomas1982

New Member
Hi,

I have a material that needs deeper explanation and help from Metabunk community. One of my acquaintances is a firm believer in paranormal (together with her family). She has had several strange experiences. Most of them could be explained by psychology. However, she gave me a recording which I would like to analyze with your help.

It is a cell phone recording of a song, which was played on a mp3 file stored in a personal computer. She has played this song many times and everything was normal. However, one time when she started it she has noticed that the whole song changed and sounded very strange. Vocals sounded distorted and ‘dark’. I am not buying her explanation – that something otherworldly has changed that recording, but I don’t have sufficient knowledge how mp3 files work and what technical problem could have caused this occurrence. This event happened to her twice while listening two different songs. At that time, she had an ordinary speaker attached to PC, which worked just fine and had no connection problem, as she claims.

I have compared undistorted version of the song with the distorted one. To me it seems that the distorted version is much slower than the normal. Therefore, the speed of playing the song may influence vocal distortion sound deeper and ‘darker’. However, I am not sure what technical process could influence and ‘change’ stored mp3 file. I would like to present her with explanation that is more plausible.

As a reference I am posting un-distorted version of the song: Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-YTpjQLUwvM
and the distorted version: Source: https://vocaroo.com/i/s1q2SeLVOVDz

Please compare the part 1:44-3:05 of the undistorted version with the part of the distorted version 0:18-2:30.

I would like to hear your opinion.

Thanks.

PS – sorry for grammar, as I am not a native English speaker
 

DasKleineTeilchen

Active Member
To me it seems that the distorted version is much slower than the normal.
and I believe thats all there is. I sped up the file to 1.5X and it sounded almost like the original one. contrary I slowed the youtube original in browser and that on the other hand sounded almost like the "distorded" one. do you know which player she used on her PC? because sometimes its easy to mistook some playerelements as something what theyre not, like for instance slow/fast-play buttons as skip to/back-to-song-buttons as illustrated here with VLC-media (a very popular player):

vlc.jpg

and as it turns out, one click on the slower-button at youtube aka one on the faster at VLC, and they sound identical vice versa

speed.jpg
This event happened to her twice while listening two different songs.
I could bet that she just accidently hit the slow-button. or she just messes with you.
However, I am not sure what technical process could influence and ‘change’ stored mp3 file.
None. its a file which doesnt change itself just-like-that at random to suddenly sound different with the same parameters at playing. and thats the only thing that can change, the parameters of the player which plays that file, like increasing the speed.
I would like to present her with explanation that is more plausible
thats all I got.
 

Thomas1982

New Member
and I believe thats all there is. I sped up the file to 1.5X and it sounded almost like the original one. contrary I slowed the youtube original in browser and that on the other hand sounded almost like the "distorded" one. do you know which player she used on her PC? because sometimes its easy to mistook some playerelements as something what theyre not, like for instance slow/fast-play buttons as skip to/back-to-song-buttons as illustrated here with VLC-media (a very popular player):

Thanks for the effort. I thought that mp3 files could have technical malfunction that would slow the recording. However, it seems that the answer lies in a player. If she didn't played it at slow speed maybe it was some other problem, who knows. I will ask her what player she uses on her computer and did she accidentally played it at slower speed but I doubt that she will remember or admit something like that.
I have played the un-distorted version of the song slower and vocal do get distorted. And when I played the distorted version faster the rhythm sounded more similar to the un-distorted version, however vocals remained distorted. I guess that by playing the recorded version of the distorted song you want get vocals sound un-distorted. I think that part of the problem might be also in quality of speakers.
I guess that psychology also play an important role in this case. As my acquaintance is convinced that the distorted voice if of foreign origin to me it seems that it is just a distorted version of the original vocals.
 
Last edited:

Whitebeard

Senior Member.
MP3 files can be corrupted, but this normally only when being transfered from one device to another, if there is an interuption in the transfer process; or if they are being converted from one format / bit rate to another - normally this is a user error caused by mismatched settings or the like. However the normal result of this corruption is that the file wont play full stop and an error message on the play back device / software.

Occasionally a softwear glitch can corrupt a file, eg I sometimes have issues with Power MP3 converter that causes the MP3 to phase badly after conversion. But I agree with Mick, this sounds like this being played at the wrong speed, it also sounds to me like this an 'airchecked' recording of an MP3 rather than the original, as I'm sure I can hear other ambient noise in the 'corrupted' version and maybe even some handling noise. Could this be an attempt at a deliberate hoax?
 

Thomas1982

New Member
Occasionally a softwear glitch can corrupt a file, eg I sometimes have issues with Power MP3 converter that causes the MP3 to phase badly after conversion. But I agree with Mick, this sounds like this being played at the wrong speed, it also sounds to me like this an 'airchecked' recording of an MP3 rather than the original, as I'm sure I can hear other ambient noise in the 'corrupted' version and maybe even some handling noise. Could this be an attempt at a deliberate hoax?

Yeah, I also thought that she maybe deliberately made that recording, but I am not good at detecting a lie. She seems to me very convinced at what she says.
What do you mean by 'airchecked'? Ambient noise in the background is probably because the sound was recorded with a cell phone so quality is low.
 

Tumeni

New Member
An 'aircheck' usually refers to a recording taken of a live radio broadcast, recorded over-the-air - i.e. the radio station has transmitted it, an end-user has received it with a receiver, and they've either placed a microphone in front of the speaker, or connected a recording device to a line output
 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
Here is additional info:

- distorted recording (recorded with cell phone while playing mp3) is 5 years old
- mp3 was played on windows media player
- 'incident' happened twice with two different songs

I don't think you are going to get any firm answers if it was five years ago. I think it's sufficient to say that playback speed can be changed, and this might have been done accidentally, or as a prank. Your friend seems predisposed to interpret things as being paranormal, but there's far more likely technological explanations that need to be eliminated before going there.
 

Thomas1982

New Member
I don't think you are going to get any firm answers if it was five years ago. I think it's sufficient to say that playback speed can be changed, and this might have been done accidentally, or as a prank. Your friend seems predisposed to interpret things as being paranormal, but there's far more likely technological explanations that need to be eliminated before going there.

I think that is a good and fair remark. I doubt that she will change her view on that case. Maybe I am to eager to debunk this one...
 

deirdre

Senior Member.
Here is additional info:

- distorted recording (recorded with cell phone while playing mp3) is 5 years old
- mp3 was played on windows media player
- 'incident' happened twice with two different songs
windows media player can be changed too. although it's not quite 'accidental', unless her kid (or someone) was playing with it without her knowledge.
3-9-2018 3-40-11 PM.png
 

Svartbjørn

Senior Member.
Thanks for the effort. I thought that mp3 files could have technical malfunction that would slow the recording

Easiest way to test that would be to have her send you the file itself and you listen to it on your end. If its not distorted then you can rule out tampering with the file. If it is, then youll have the file available to open up in audio software to see if someone's changed the playback speed or otherwise messed with the recording.
 

Thomas1982

New Member
Everyone, thanks for the help. You really did help me sort out possible solutions of the problem. It seems to me that we are left with four scenarios:

1. Mp3 file was corrupted - I can't check that as she doesn't have it anymore. She claims that before that incident and after it the song was ok. I think this scenario is not likely.
2. Mp3 was deliberately played on slow motion so it sounds 'mysterious'
3. Somehow she accidentaly played the file on slow motion - that would explain a lot, but how would settings go back to normal after that as she didn't mention that she was changing player settings after the 'incident'. I doub't that someone messed wit her as she doesn't have kids, sieblings or roommates living with her.
4. There was somekind of a player/computer technical bug that caused the song to sound distorted/garbled - (if you google 'windows media player plays slow' you get articles which say that wmp can occasionaly play slow due to various factors). Who knows what was done on a computer during the 'incident'.

I would go with the number 4 (with this I presume that she is not a manipulator but I can't be 100% sure of that).
 
Last edited:
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
Edward Current Needs Debunking: That the GPS does not implement time corrections from Einstein's relativity Science and Pseudoscience 7
A Needs Debunking: Proposed COVID Vaccine will become part of our DNA, make us programmable Coronavirus COVID-19 10
gtoffo Needs Debunking: "UFO crash" near Rio de Janeiro UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 17
Code-Beta Needs Debunking: CE-5, humans initiating UFO sightings UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 8
Mick West Debunking Correlations Between 5G deployments and Coronavirus Coronavirus COVID-19 14
Pumpernickel Need Debunking: Foucault's Pendulum debunked through Mach's principle (the Earth is a static object in the center of the Universe) Science and Pseudoscience 16
Mick West TFTRH #34 - Stian Arnesen: Debunking, Censorship, 9/11, and UFOs Tales From the Rabbit Hole Podcast 0
H Need Debunking: Hernando County platforms from more than 10 miles Flat Earth 9
Bill Statler Needs debunking: "Magnetic water" for treating diabetes Health and Quackery 8
Mick West TFTRH #14: Rory – Flat Earth Debunking and Spiritual Journeys Tales From the Rabbit Hole Podcast 6
Qulaey Two problems need help debunking and debating tips? please. Flat Earth 9
Scaramanga The Easy And Logical Debunking Of UFO 'Size' UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 1
Mendel MediaWise #IsThisLegit program Practical Debunking 1
brad fuller Does the inverse-square law apply to the flat-earth debunking tool chest? Flat Earth 4
mudr0 Need Debunking: Video claiming zigzaggin objects and movement prove EVA filmed in pool General Discussion 33
vooke Need debunking: Writings in the sky Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 11
Mick West Debunking 9/11 Microsphere Myths 9/11 0
Starman Debunking Bob Lazar's drawing of S-4 hangers UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 15
Mick West Debunking Guidelines for: "Convex Earth - The Documentary" Flat Earth 0
Mick West Here's to the "Debunker"! Practical Debunking 1
ConfusedHominid Need Debunking (Claim): Metabunk Curve Calculator Does Not Calculate for Angular Size Flat Earth 13
Mick West NY Times: In Italian Schools, Reading, Writing and Recognizing Fake News Practical Debunking 60
Mick West Debunking: A Meta-Analysis of the Psychological Efficacy of Messages Countering Misinformation Practical Debunking 5
Rory Where online is debunking most effective? Practical Debunking 14
Whitebeard Martymer 81 Practical Debunking 4
N Neeson's anti-debunking thoughts Site Feedback & News 15
Mick West Fireproof Cabbage, Burning Snow, Flat Earth - Are Some Things too Silly to Debunk? Practical Debunking 7
Mick West Burying the Debunk: How Fake News about "Pyramids" in Antarctica Creates False Balance UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 2
Mick West Debunking911.com offline - How to Preserve Good Debunking Sites? 9/11 3
Sam Hill Debunking "That's not a Space Station, it's an airplane" Flat Earth 1
Mick West When Absence of Evidence is Evidence of Absence in Conspiracy Theories Practical Debunking 35
Rogerpenna Debunking Flat Earth with the Southern Hemisphere Flat Earth 11
Leifer Polite video interviewing/debunking Practical Debunking 8
Veronica! Any resources for debunking a 'cold case' UFO sighting? Practical Debunking 7
M Flat Earth theory simple debunking by the moon's appearance Flat Earth 48
mrfintoil Study: When Debunking Scientific Myths Fails (and When It Does Not) Practical Debunking 3
deirdre study on how to 'sway people' Practical Debunking 0
Leifer Pseudo debunking, trickery, product promos Health and Quackery 10
MikeG College Course on Conspiracies Practical Debunking 89
Leifer Harriet Hall, on debunking methods Practical Debunking 2
keefe Debunking guide Practical Debunking 3
Critical Thinker Why we debunk and who do we reach. Practical Debunking 2
G Needs debunking: Video of a solar eclipse is fake because we cannot see the moon covering the sun Flat Earth 5
Trigger Hippie Russian Troll Houses Practical Debunking 24
Mick West Finding the Original Source in a World of Aggregators, Shares, and Reposts Practical Debunking 32
David Ridlen Earth curvature refraction experiments - debunking flat/concave Earth Flat Earth 344
Mackdog Google to start debunking General Discussion 21
SabreSaint Need Debunking: CERN To Recreate Big Bang Science and Pseudoscience 26
Mick West Charlie Hebdo Conspiracy Theories - Ignore or Address? Conspiracy Theories 255
Pete Tar Vox article on Debunking, avoiding The Backfire Effect Practical Debunking 0
Related Articles


















































Related Articles

Top