Why 9/11 Truthers Are Wrong About The Facts | (Part 1 w/ Mick West)

aSkepticalHuman

New Member
Source: https://youtu.be/uO4W7IbdwsI
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Jeffrey Orling

Senior Member
I have not read the book (yet)... but not unlike many people my first exposure to "explanations" for 9/11 was a video.. likely Loose Change of CIT's (can't recall the name). I was not convinced by these presentations, but it raised my curiosity as to HOW such buildings could collapse. I followed my curiosity over the AE911T because I am an architect and I figured a professional group of architects and engineers interested in the collapse would have done some study and be able to shed light on the collapses. I got into that group for a few months....Gage put me on their board. But it was almost immediately apparent that AE911T was not a collection of professionals study the performance of the buildings... but a group to market CD which at the time was nano thermite. I realized this was nothing more than a cult to raise money to raise money.
Then I discovered other internet sites/resources and especially 911FreeForum which has a bunch of engineers who were analyzing the videos and doing all manner of physics calculations. Some refuted truther claims, some flaws in NISTs work, many discussions of other researchers and lots of critical thinking. There were only a few truthers there such as Szamboti who got his ass handed to him and his missing jolt and other rubbish shown to be just that. Nothing would convince Tony and he remains down the rabbit hole.
You can perhaps excuse laymen for falling down the rabbit hole... but you can excuse scientists, engineers and architects who have taken the time to study the collapse as was done by the engineers at 911FreeForum. What was "clear" is that exactly what happened may never be known because of the dearth of data from the event. All that can be done is model what COULD have happened and try to support it with physics and engineering and the evidence/data that did exist. So there could be no "proofs" only well reason (or less well reasoned) theories explaining the building collapses.
Truth groups don't bother with any level of detail in a comprehensive sequence of event... they short cut by use explosives and nano thermite and lots of mystery. They make claims of free fall which mean nothing... that is not a sign of free fall or a proof of it.
Some will debunk bits and pieces truther claims... like the missing jolt or nano thermite. None of this debunking seems to convince those down the rabbit hole.

The more interesting 9/11 phenomena is the mass psychology and how these cults form... or fall down the rabbit hole which shares properties with a black hole or the Hotel California... where you can check in but can't check out.

For those who want to learn about engineering, physics, highrise buildings, aviation etc... the study of 9/11 is fertile ground... Watch out for the rabbit holes! ;-)
 
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
MikeC Metabunk linked from Cracked.com article on "Truthers" Sandy Hook 2
Mick West 9/11 Conspiracy Theories: Inside The Lonely Lives Of Truthers, Still Looking For Their Big Break 9/11 46
moderateGOP 9/11 truthers Invade Muslim March Conspiracy Theories 4
mynym 911 truthers on the WSJ? 9/11 2
Twenty2AcaciaAve The Prof/Engineer list that truthers always talk about. 9/11 47
S Among the Truthers (Book and Web Site) 9/11 1
Mick West Why Michio Kaku is wrong about the UFO Burden of Proof & Navy Videos UFO Videos and Reports from the US Navy 32
MikeG Everything wrong with Hillary Clinton/Medical Conspiracies Conspiracy Theories 8
Efftup I might be wrong on this......... for once. General Discussion 10
Asylumkid Conrad Michael's $10,000 reward to prove him wrong about contrails. Contrails and Chemtrails 53
Mick West Debunked: The latest ISIS video of two Japanese men is a fake, shadows wrong [Perspective] Conspiracy Theories 109
cmnit Debunked: Tankerenemy - Contrails at 13,000 feet? [Wrong Plane] Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 15
CaptainBeefheart Debunked: Ottawa Shooting Hoax/Shadow's Prove Wrong Times Conspiracy Theories 13
derwoodii Debunked: Claim MH 17 wreckage engine fan is wrong size Flight MH17 2
vooke Was Inmarsat Wrong? Flight MH370 5
Cube Radio Debunked: The "Fat" Bin Laden Video. [Wrong aspect ratio] 9/11 74
AluminumTheory Conspiracists and Skeptics: (in your opinion) What is Wrong with the World Today? General Discussion 4
TrueFiction The Wrong Colored Backpack Boston Marathon Bombings 244
Cairenn Waco, TX, Fertilizer Explosion: Illustration of how the wrong information gets posted General Discussion 13
HappyMonday Leading Environmental Activist’s Confession: I Was Completely Wrong To Oppose GMO's Conspiracy Theories 44
Leifer TED Talk: When a "memory expert" get it wrong.... General Discussion 12
Dan Wilson Debunked: Terrifying Facts About Makeup Health and Quackery 1
Related Articles






















Related Articles

Top