Debunked: Ian Simpson's Presentation at the 2015 Cambridge SRM Conference

[Ray Von Geezer]

Ian spoke of posting more vid, possibly including his interaction with Keith. I'd like to see what Keith actually said.

He put it up a while ago (it's actually just audio as David Keith declined to be video'd).

I can't play audio at the moment so I can't quote timestamps, but from memory I'm sure David Keith says that he hasn't seen the "Smokers" video. One thing he definitely does is school Ian in how to "science"



*edit* - Have listened again, at around the 10:00 mark David Keith says "I mean I don't even know what video you're talking about". Ian brings the "Smokers" video up constantly.

Ray Von

 

[Hama Neggs]

He put it up a while ago (it's actually just audio as David Keith declined to be video'd).

I can't play audio at the moment so I can't quote timestamps, but from memory I'm sure David Keith says that he hasn't seen the "Smokers" video. One thing he definitely does is school Ian in how to "science"



Ray Von

So having not seen something is "denial" in Ian's mind.

 

[Hama Neggs]

Wow. Ian thinks "black smoke" is C02

PS: He also now is claiming that there are "hundreds of planes" pumping out his "black smoke" and that it is created by fossil fuels being dumped into the exhaust streams of aircraft.

Keith really did do a good job of putting the onus back on Ian.

 

[deirdre]

and that it is created by fossil fuels being dumped into the exhaust streams of aircraft

OT- speaking of the cost of wasting fossil fuels, I just filled my own gas tank yesterday and it only cost me 20$ to fill my tank- less than half of last time I looked at my receipt! was new legislation passed or is it just because it's spring now?

 

[Ray Von Geezer]

Wow. Ian thinks "black smoke" is C02

PS: He also now is claiming that there are "hundreds of planes" pumping out his "black smoke" and that it is created by fossil fuels being dumped into the exhaust streams of aircraft.

Keith really did do a good job of putting the onus back on Ian.

I know. Ian has repeatedly ignored (and deleted/blocked) people who've tried to explain just why that doesn't make any sense.

Did Ian sound like he was squirming a little when Keith suggested they both put their money where their mouths are? I think so

Ray Von

 

[Balance]

Reference to Ian's claim he's proved fleets of planes are covertly pumping thick black smoke into the atmosphere contributing very significantly to Co2 emissions;
Asked to quantify or explain what does major contribution mean to you, Ian's response was I dunno, I'm not a scientist.

 

[Balance]

Cool, David Keith has extended advice to Ian how to get the scientists on his side. I trust he'll take full advantage of this golden opportunity as it's surely just the break they're all looking for?

 

[Pete Tar]

For those who wish to engage chris's questions: https://www.metabunk.org/threads/chrisjones-questions-on-ian-simpson.6113/