CLAIM: 1950 McMinnville (OR) photo by the Trents is a 25' flying saucer

The plate is certainly a possibility, the advantage of the truck mirror is that it comes with the post jutting out at an angle pre-existing, no drilling or gluing required.. The lazyology principle, or some corollary thereof, would suggest that for a given hoax picture, where two or more explanations for how the hoax was done cover the existing facts equally well, the option that requires the least effort from a hoaxer is at least somewhat more likely to be correct.

delme.jpg



Note that the slanted "antenna" sticking out the top is not a feature common to a lot of other UFO pics -- this is another example of how (as far as I have seen) no two UFO pics that are clear enough to see something of the structure of the object seem to show the same "make and model" of ship -- they're all slightly different. It seems unlikely that fleets of ships flown by visiting aliens would be nothing but custom one-offs (though not impossible, who knows what aliens might do!) but seems very likely for a series of hoaxers taking advantage of whatever came to hand that looked a it like a flying saucer and tossing it in the air or hanging it from a string.
 
The plate is certainly a possibility, the advantage of the truck mirror is that it comes with the post jutting out at an angle pre-existing, no drilling or gluing required.. The lazyology principle
I agree. It's just that I haven't found a single mirror with the right silhouette. The flat top of the "ufo" is quite apparent in Trent's photo, but it's not typical of this kind of mirror.
IMG_2597.png
 
Off-topic a bit,, but a tin or aluminium plate would be light, cheap and easy to punch a hole through for a suspension point. They were very common in the 20th century.
Indeed, a metal plate is a very good match. They also described the object as silvery. If they knew it was an aluminum plate, describing it that way would make perfect sense.

There's an interesting aspect of the case that is often overlooked by those who are more inclined to believe than to search for the truth. It concerns the Trents as witnesses and whether they might have had a motive to hoax the photographs. In the Oregonian of June 10, 1950, Evelyn Trent is reported to have "seen similar objects on the coast three different times, but no one would believe me".
IMG_3873.jpeg

In other words, Evelyn was already a repeat UFO observer when she and her husband allegedly saw the object come zooming toward their small farm. Paul also appears to have been well aware of the "flying saucer mystery" long before he took the photographs. Quoted in the Pasadena Independent of June 11, 1950, he said: "I was kinda scared of it. You know, you hear so much talk about those things, and the government…"
IMG_3874.jpeg

To summarize, we have Evelyn, who believed she had seen flying saucers on several occasions, but whose friends did not believe her, and Paul, who had discussed the phenomenon and had heard a great deal about it. Witnesses like these must be considered in their proper context.

Evelyn may have seen "things" that she believed were flying saucers. It is obviously impossible to know what she actually saw, but the experience may have affected her deeply. If so, she would have carried that prior experience with her when the events of May 11 occurred.
 
I'm a fairly analogue kind of person. Not because I have anything against digital tools, but because I find that building a physical scale model really helps me understand the layout and geometry of a location.
IMG_6530.jpeg

IMG_6528.jpeg

IMG_6529.jpeg

I've been working quite a bit on the Trent case over the past few months, so I decided to build a simple 1:14 scale model of the Trents' small farm. Paul's approximate positions when he took the two photographs are marked with white crosses, and the short distance he moved between the shots is illustrated in the video below.

My report on the case is almost finished, and in it I've attempted to examine the case in its entirety. (I'll share the report as soon as it's ready.) Personally, though, I feel that the geometry and physical layout of the location alone are enough to conclude that this was a remarkably simple hoax, something one can pull off in a few minutes without any deeper knowledge in photography. Speculation about atmospheric haze and other unfounded claims starts to feel a bit like people searching for muscle movements beneath Patterson and Gimlin's ape costume.

I also tried recreating the photographs using a 12 cm coffee saucer suspended completely motionless in mid-air by two fishing lines. I did my best to approximate Trent's original camera and lens setup using my modern camera, positioned the saucer at the same distance from the camera as a model suspended beneath the Trents' two overhead power lines would have been, and then reproduced the same camera movement Trent made between the two photographs. (My two photos are circled in red, and the Trent photos are included as a reference.)
IMG_6533.jpeg

Well, what can I say? The saucer's apparent rotation, motion, and slight change in size can all be explained entirely by the movement of the camera. There's simply no need for a rotating or swinging model. All it takes is an ordinary porcelain saucer hanging perfectly still, just beneath the power lines, barely three metres above the ground, just within reach for Paul when using the wooden six foot ladder we know he had access to.
IMG_6535.jpeg
 
Back
Top