False Narrative: "North Tower Antenna Dropped Before Roof Line"

Joe Hill

Member
Richard Gage's AE911Truth organization asserts the North Tower antenna dropped straight down into the building at the beginning of collapse, and claims that is evidence the core columns had to be cut with cutter charges. The claim is made in the video, "9/11 Explosive Evidence - Experts Speak Out", at 53:20 here: As recently as March, 2018, one of the key AE911Truth engineers repeated the claim as fact:
It is clear that the antenna dropping before the exterior roofline in the North Tower collapse shows it was a core column failure that pulled the exterior columns inward and initiated the collapse.
Having found no rebuttal of Szamboti's premise, it seems appropriate, for the record, to submit a thread on the topic. The assertion is patently false, easily discernible by studying collapse initiation from east or west. I used a video taken from the west, on the Hudson river:
It's clear the tower top section and antenna are tilting south as one unit to begin collapse. The motion indicates that the core initially served as the fulcrum for the rotating motion of the tower top, buckled, and was quickly ripped apart.
A closer look shows clearly the antenna did not drop into the building:
NTtiltannotated.png

Gage and Szamboti use only a view from the north, the optics of which are illustrated here:
NTtiltAEanalysis.png

Editorial comment:
It is unfathomable that professional architect and engineer researchers would fail to study initiation of collapse from all angles. Initiation, or onset, is actually all that matters in determining why a structure collapsed. It is clear onset of the North Tower was due to failure of the south wall, not the core. The south wall gradually formed an inward sink, long before onset of collapse, seen below, and there is no sign of core failure until after the tower top started tilting south. For Gage and Szamboti to still claim the core failed first reveals utter sloppiness, or outright bias/deceit, neither worthy of the "Truth" moniker.
WTC1_Fire_Anotaded_Crop.png
 
Last edited:

econ41

Senior Member
...As recently as March, 2018, one of the key AE911Truth engineers repeated the claim as fact:

Having found no rebuttal of Szamboti's premise, it seems appropriate, for the record, to submit a thread on the topic.
Agreed that there may not be any rebuttal on this forum of Szamboti's specific claim about antenna drop >> caused by core column cutting. Your comments about geometry and viewpoint are probably sufficient of themselves to cast doubt on Szamboti's claim. However I suggest that comprehensive rebuttal is best framed in the context of the "tower top section and antenna are tilting south as one unit to begin collapse". i.e. the full context of the role played by the "Top Block" in the initiation stage...not just the antenna itself.

I'll put some comments in line:
The assertion is patently false, << Agreed easily discernible by studying collapse initiation from east or west. << and also by comprehending the mechanism of Top Block movement ......
It's clear the tower top section and antenna are tilting south as one unit to begin collapse. << Yes The motion indicates that the core initially served as the fulcrum for the rotating motion of the tower top, buckled, and was quickly ripped apart. << I'll offer an alternate explanation for both those points. You accept as premise that the top section tilted as one unit. That suggests that core columns were also failing to allow the tilt. And the "ripping apart" of the "Top Block" occurred later - as the Top Block fell bodily - graphical evidence in a later post.
A closer look shows clearly the antenna did not drop into the building: << Yes - a conclusion supported by your video evidence and also flowing from analysis of the mechanism.

Gage and Szamboti use only a view from the north, the optics of which are illustrated here:
View attachment 37790
<< Fully agreed and probably strong enough as a stand alone argument.

It is unfathomable that professional architect and engineer researchers would fail to study initiation of collapse from all angles. Initiation, or onset, is actually all that matters in determining why a structure collapsed.
Agreed both points.

It is clear onset of the North Tower was due to failure of the south wall, not the core. The south wall gradually formed an inward sink, long before onset of collapse, seen below, and there is no sign of core failure until after the tower top started tilting south.
This is the aspect that IMO needs discussion. The observed fact that the Top Blocks... both of them ... tilted as integral single units conflicts with the asserted no failure of core. We need to be very clear what stage we are discussing. My contention being that the Top Block maintained most of its structural integrity as it tilted - therefore the tilting resulted from differential shortening of columns whether perimeter or core. The integrity of the Top Blocks was destroyed after they started to fall bodily - the Top Block and upper levels of lower tower in mutual destruction... The analogous mechanism for both towers notwithstanding the greater tilt for WTC2.
For Gage and Szamboti to still claim the core failed first reveals utter sloppiness, or outright bias/deceit, neither worthy of the "Truth" moniker.
The underlying issue is that none of the AE911 technical leaders understand the actual mechanism of the collapses. Especially at this stage and the transition into "progression". Both Szamboti and Chandler making similar errors.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
Richard Gage's AE911Truth organization asserts the North Tower antenna dropped straight down into the building at the beginning of collapse, and claims that is evidence the core columns had to be cut with cutter charges. The claim is made in the video, "9/11 Explosive Evidence - Experts Speak Out", at 53:20 here:
I don't think that's a great example. He just says:
 

Joe Hill

Member
That suggests that core columns were also failing to allow the tilt.
Indeed. Core columns would have to buckle, bend, kink, sink, in order for the upper block to tilt. They could still function as fulcrum for observable motion of the upper block while sustaining such failures. Whether it was the core or south wall that initiated vertical failure of the building however, is off topic, and I probably shouldn't have commented on it. :oops:

And the "ripping apart" of the "Top Block" occurred later
The "ripping apart" I referred to was the core structure, not the top block. Based simply on motion of the top block, over, then over and down, then down, in rapid succession, the core structure quickly ripped apart.

We need to be very clear what stage we are discussing.
Agreed, and imo, there is nothing more important than initiation, in as tight a frame as is observable.

I don't think that's a great example. He just says:
Relative to, "and claims that is evidence the core columns had to be cut with cutter charges" (OP), I agree. I considered that axiomatic.
The video reference was to show that AE uses a view which makes it appear the antenna is sinking as an initial movement, not necessarily the accompanying dialogue.
Relative to the thread topic however,
"00:53:11,309 --> 00:53:19,890 before the towers
00:53:16,349 --> 00:53:24,829 started collapsing from the top the
00:53:19,890 --> 00:53:27,839 antenna started to fall", confirms AE claims the antenna moved, "fell", before any other part of the building.
 
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
J [False] Claim that Scale Model of 2017 Eclipse Disproves the Heliocentric Model Flat Earth 29
Whitebeard Christchurch (NZ) Mosque Shootings Current Events 20
Mick West Explosive Devices sent to Clintons, Brennan (at CNN), Soros Current Events 97
Mick West Explosions at Rally for Venezuelan President Maduro - Drones? Assassination? False Flag? Current Events 31
Mick West Russian Claims of a "False Flag" Chemical Weapons Attack in Douma, Syria Current Events 10
Whitebeard Sergei Skripal 'Nerve Agent' Attack Current Events 46
Mick West Hawaii Ballistic Missile False Alarm Current Events 13
Mick West Debunked: US "False Flag" Plan to Start War with the USSR [Cuba Intervention Pretext Idea] Conspiracy Theories 1
Mick West Las Vegas Shooting Creates Huge Spike in Searches for "False Flag" Current Events 33
Joe Debunked: Iconic Charlottesville photo photoshopped; false flag Conspiracy Theories 29
Qualiall Syria Chemical Attack 2017 Current Events 49
Z.W. Wolf Screwed, Blewed and Tattooed - False Etymologies General Discussion 1
Mick West Burying the Debunk: How Fake News about "Pyramids" in Antarctica Creates False Balance UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 2
Mick West False Authority: "Thoughts From a Former NIST Employee" on 9/11 9/11 92
Abishua Claim: water in moonlight cools faster than water not in moonlight [False] Science and Pseudoscience 160
M Bornong "Something Strange" - Hurriyah car bombing video seems staged General Discussion 50
Leifer False: Identify GMO tomatoes in 2 easy steps Health and Quackery 4
Mick West Debunked: US "Caught Repainting Fighter Jets" for False Flag [2014 Training] Conspiracy Theories 23
deirdre Debunked: Blanketman photo proves Nice attack a false flag Conspiracy Theories 2
Mick West Pete Santilli's Malheur (Burns, Oregon) FBI False Flag Conspiracy Theory Conspiracy Theories 4
NotQualified Claim:"Largest bio-terrorism drill in California's history recently took place in San Bernardino" General Discussion 4
MikeC San Bernardino - false flag accusations start within minutes.... General Discussion 72
Jean-François A false quote attributed to Aldous Huxley Quotes Debunked 28
David Ridlen Debunked: The Flat Earth Theory. 14 Ways the Flat Earth Theory is False Flat Earth 11
MikeG Claim: Charleston Shooting was a False Flag Conspiracy Theories 22
Mick West Charlie Hebdo Conspiracy Theories - Ignore or Address? Conspiracy Theories 255
Whitebeard Claim - 'Sydney Chocolate Shop is a False Flag' Conspiracy Theories 72
CaptainBeefheart Claim: Fake CPR at Ottawa Shooting Proves Hoax Conspiracy Theories 17
Redwood Debunked: Google photos show Ottawa Parliament bullet holes are fake Conspiracy Theories 115
Mick West Debunking False Flags about Canadian Parliament and War Memorial Shootings in Ottawa Conspiracy Theories 21
CapnPegleg Vegas Police Officers Shot - False Flag claims coming? Conspiracy Theories 32
Tobes Debunked: Movie producer Nathan Folks claims bombing false flag, Voice of Russia says blood too red Boston Marathon Bombings 134
Soulfly Flight MH370 missing - Two passengers board with false ID Flight MH370 48
gerrycan AE911 Letter to Inspector General Claims NIST WTC7 Report is Provably False 9/11 161
AluminumTheory Anonymous: False Flag 9/11 Style Attack in LA in May Be Imminent (on or around November 15th) Conspiracy Theories 16
Mick West LAX Shooting Conspiracy Theories - Los Angeles Airport - False Flag Theories Conspiracy Theories 526
mrfintoil Discussion: False memories and "No persistent trails in the past" Contrails and Chemtrails 46
Mick West Washington Navy Yard Shootings - False Flag Conspiracy Theories? Conspiracy Theories 73
TruthSeeker YouTube claim: "Massive Methane Foam Worldwide" True or False UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 14
Mick West Kumaré: A True Film About a False Prophet General Discussion 0
ThorGoLucky Power Balance admits false claims Health and Quackery 2
Mick West TFTRH #32 - The Skeptic of the North: Former Conspiracist, Current Skeptic Tales From the Rabbit Hole Podcast 1
Joe Hill Debunked: "The North Face of Building 7 Was Pulled Inward" 9/11 66
Mendel Homemade Gyrocompass finds North by Spin Flat Earth 0
Sascha North-South flights Flat Earth 10
Clouds Givemethewillies North Wales beneath the sea Flat Earth 10
TEEJ Virgin Atlantic Airbus - Different coloured contrails, Kernersville, North Carolina 16th March 2016 Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 13
Mackdog Claim: SONY hack was inside job Conspiracy Theories 6
FuzzyUK North magnetic pole moved 160 miles in 6 months? Conspiracy Theories 15
Mick West Debunked: Michael Hastings Crash Engine Found North of Crash going South? Conspiracy Theories 43
Related Articles


















































Related Articles

Top