Claim: Robert Parry: Australian 60 Minutes fudged evidence to pin blame on Russia

Morty

New Member
Australian 60 Minutes recently ran a story claiming to locate the very spot from which a Russian made missile was launched to down flight MH17.

60 minutes story here (12 minutes): http://www.9jumpin.com.au/show/60minutes/stories/2015/may/mh17/

Robert Parry has written an article claiming that the final "slam dunk" photographic evidence offered by 60 Minutes doesn't match the scene as claimed by 60 Minutes.

Robert Parry article: https://consortiumnews.com/2015/05/18/fake-evidence-blaming-russia-for-mh-17/

Verdict: I don't know enough to say, either way, but seeing as things are so slow here at the Metabunk MH17 forum, I'm willing to endure a scolding for this lazy, non-complying OP to see if any sharper minds out there have an opinion on this, one way or the other.
 

Pete Tar

Senior Member.
This seems to be the main claim -



He didn't really prove much.
 

Trailblazer

Moderator
Staff member
I haven't looked into these claims in detail but I can easily believe that those screenshots show exactly the same place. A lot of people get confused by the massive effect that changes in camera position and, especially, focal length, can have in the appearance of a scene.

For example, these three pictures all show the same house:







upload_2015-5-22_10-39-46.png


From telephoto to wide angle (and obviously a big change in viewpoint from the first one).
 

Cairenn

Senior Member.
The mountains don't even look real similar and they look to be very different distances from the house.
 

Morty

New Member
Thanks for the replies. I'm surprised Parry is willing to be so sloppy. I guess he's just saying what his audience wants to hear.

I'd be interested to know if anybody sees any contradictions between the scenario outlined by bellingcat/60 Minutes and the accepted wisdom here at Metabunk regarding the facts of flight MH17.
 

Pete Tar

Senior Member.
I wouldn't call 60 minutes good journalism by any standards (it's generally that awful modern style where the reporter and their experience is considered the star of the story), but I doubt they fabricated any evidence to make the segment.
Didn't they pretty much just gather and repeat all the evidence that was being discussed on the internet when it happened, or did they have something new to add?
 

Mi3

New Member
I'm going with Parry at this stage. I watched the 60 mins program on Sunday and immediately didn't buy their story due to weak evidence and jumping to conclusions. I had a quick look at the photos and am not going to waste a lot of time but it hasn't convinced me.

So you really think those poles from original BUK video and from 60min are not the same ?

 

David Coulter

Senior Member.
There seems to be quite a few logic flaws in the Parry piece. Lets start with this one.

It seems to me that people would be more likely to be looking for and photographing equipment on the move after MH17 was shot down than before. They may not of even known what a BUK looked like the day before the incident - why bother taking pictures of military equipment on trucks?

The argument seems to be appealing to hindsight.
 

David Coulter

Senior Member.
This seems to be the main claim -



He didn't really prove much.


I had concerns about the open nature of the field when the imagery first came out. But if you look at post #2 you can see that the photo was taken with a long lens from some distance away and the "forest of trees" is actually a foreshortened view of the scattered trees. Given the tension at the time it makes sense that a photographer would not be standing right next to the road, especially if they were trying to get candid/clandestine shots of military equipment.

As for Parry making an issue about the video of the correspondent in the open field, it is a red herring. It would not make sense to set up a correspondent shot from several hundred yards away so that the viewpoint matched the BUK photography - the audio would be problematic.
 

David Coulter

Senior Member.
Here is my theory:

Russians provide some basic training on BUKs to some Cossacks.
Russians provide a few BUKs to shoot down Ukranian transport and supply planes.
Poory trained Cossack turns on his BUK in independent operation mode before the full array is in place with IFF capability.
Cossack shoots down MH17 thinking it is a Ukrainian supply plane and he will be the hero of the day.
Russians take the guns away from the children within 24 hours.

The last part is geopolitical...
The West does not want to start WWIII over it.
 

TEEJ

Senior Member.
It is interesting that the Luhansk billboard car advert was later photographed with part of it torn off.

upload_2015-5-26_19-16-29.png

From

http://www.whathappenedtoflightmh17...buk-missing-1-missile-driving-towards-russia/



The torn area just happened to be the area where the Russian Ministry of Defence claimed that the car advert carried an address in Krasnoarmeisk.



The Russians have never retracted their claim of Krasnoarmeisk.

They still have the transcription of the press conference on the Russian UK Embassy website.

http://www.rusemb.org.uk/press/1865



 

Trailblazer

Moderator
Staff member
It is interesting that the Luhansk billboard car advert was later photographed with part of it torn off.

View attachment 13080

From

http://www.whathappenedtoflightmh17...buk-missing-1-missile-driving-towards-russia/



The torn area just happened to be the area where the Russian Ministry of Defence claimed that the car advert carried an address in Krasnoarmeisk.



The Russians have never retracted their claim of Krasnoarmeisk.

They still have the transcription of the press conference on the Russian UK Embassy website.

http://www.rusemb.org.uk/press/1865

The banner which was torn does not match the graphic: note that the phone numbers are different. Bogdan Auto has numerous locations across Ukraine.






The phone number on the billboard is (0642) 31-10-16. Googling that phone number brings up this address on the Bogdan Autocentres website: http://bogdanauto.autocentre.ua/bogdan-autocentres.html

upload_2015-5-26_20-51-32.png


The address is г. Луганск, кв-л Ленинского комсомола, 1В.

Transliterated: Leninskogo Komsomola 1B, Luhansk.

Luhansk, not Krasnoarmeysk.

It's impossible to read the text above the phone number on that photo, but it appears from the length of the words that it could well say "Ленинского комсомола 1В":

upload_2015-5-26_20-58-43.png


Edit: the full image confirms that that is the address:



https://www.metabunk.org/data/MetaMirrorCache/4ece2b117da2d8226c0f04f08c649643.jpg

Translated Russian text in above graphic:

(left) What "nanotechnology" allowed this address to be read as Krasnoarmeysk? :)

(right) This billboard has the address on it in plain view. (literally "the light of day and the address on it")

I am still unable to get the 60 Minutes video to play, so this may be addressed already in the video?
 
Last edited:

David Coulter

Senior Member.
I get suspicious when someone like Parry slightly modifies the meaning of quotes.

He says:
But the story says:
That is a subtle misrepresentation of what Der Spiegel reported but there is a very big difference between an indication of something and conclusive evidence.

....my emphasis....
 

TEEJ

Senior Member.
Translated Russian text in above graphic:

(left) What "nanotechnology" allowed this address to be read as Krasnoarmeysk? :)

(right) This billboard has the address on it in plain view. (literally "the light of day and the address on it")

Nice work. I agree. Looks like the Russians just ran with the social media claim of Krasnoarmeysk. Translation of that
original post on Facebook. You would have thought that the Russians would have double-checked and at least attempted to geo-locate the Krasnoarmeysk claim from the video? All very strange and leads me to believe that it was a deliberate attempt by the Russian military/intelligence to muddy the waters.

upload_2015-5-26_22-51-56.png

https://www.facebook.com/KNNUK/posts/735639363159197
 

Rob

Member
Bellingcat presented a compelling argument that not just 60 Minutes Australia DID record their images in the right place in Luhansk, but also that the video of the BUK with the missing missile was indeed recorded at that very same location :

https://www.bellingcat.com/news/uk-...n-in-depth-analysis-of-the-luhansk-buk-video/

So Robert Parry's argument that 60 Minutes Australia "faked" evidence (and later accusations by Robert Parry of "fraud") are entirely without merit and entirely unfounded.
Meanwhile, Robert Parry has not presented ANY evidence himself, other than a mis-interpretation of perspective, as nicely explained in 'Trailblazer's post above.

Mick, What kind of evidence do we need to present so that this thread can be flagged as "DEBUNKED" ?
Or is there a category like "UNFOUNDED" or "SLANDER" or so ?
 

Pete Tar

Senior Member.
You'd have to summarise the points/counter-points in a post. Then they could be edited in to the opening post.
 

deirdre

Senior Member.
You'd have to summarise the points/counter-points in a post. Then they could be edited in to the opening post.
i did have alot of trouble following the thread because the pics were spaced out, the names were all funny and i dont know where any of those places are on the map or the story behind the russia billboard story.
 
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
P Claim: UFO Black Knight Satellite spotted over Philippines UFO Videos and Reports from the US Navy 2
Mick West Explained: Trump's Claim of Suspicious Early Morning Michigan Bump [It's Detroit] Election 2020 1
Mick West Claim: R-Squared Coefficient of Determination as a Election Fraud Signal Election 2020 5
Akton Claim: Ballots in Wayne County were run through the tabulator and counted as many as 4-5 times Election 2020 16
Mick West Trump's Claim that "THE OBSERVERS WERE NOT ALLOWED INTO THE COUNTING ROOMS." Election 2020 6
P Claim: Authorities supressed alleged UFO findings of a reporter of the 1965 Kecksburg crash UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 7
M Claim: Hints of life on Venus: Scientists detect phosphine molecules in high cloud decks UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 20
Shade sitter Claim: Covid vaccine gives you "Serpent" DNA/marks you 666 Coronavirus COVID-19 9
P Claim: Ronald Reagan warned the world of aliens/alien invasion UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 4
P Claim: Man took photo of an alien spacecraft in 2016 UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 21
Arugula Claim: Only 6% of COVID deaths are "real" - the rest died due to comorbidities Coronavirus COVID-19 11
P Claim: Finding of potentially chemiluminescent compound in soil proves aliens landed UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 11
M Claim: UFO performs sharp maneuver after laser pointer directly hits craft UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 20
Critical Thinker Claim: Correlations Between Media Preference and Coronavirus Infection Rates Coronavirus COVID-19 11
L Claim: NASA is doctoring an image [Scanner Dirt] UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 7
Z.W. Wolf Claim: Martin Gugino Was Using a "Police Tracker." Conspiracy Theories 42
Rory Claim: A dog in Manchester could sense its owner's return by unknown means UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 21
jarlrmai Claim: UFO following jet into landing at JFK on 11/11/19 UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 15
Dingo Claim: U.S. Covid-19 Deaths are being Artificially Inflated Coronavirus COVID-19 38
W Claim: The Heart Is Not A Pump Health and Quackery 6
J Another sun path claim Flat Earth 4
J Claim sun paths prove flat earth Flat Earth 41
R Claim: Apollo 15-17 Live TV Feed - Antenna signal would be interrupted from all the violent shaking when Astronauts touch the buggy General Discussion 26
Rory Claim: Spanish flu caused by radio waves Coronavirus COVID-19 3
J [False] Claim that Scale Model of 2017 Eclipse Disproves the Heliocentric Model Flat Earth 29
Rory Claim: UK Coronavirus Bill (HC Bill 122) means "bad things" Coronavirus COVID-19 9
Mick West Claim: China Mobile loses 8.116 Million subscribers because of Coronavirus Coronavirus COVID-19 2
Agent K Claim: Harvey Weinstein has coronavirus Coronavirus COVID-19 9
Mick West Claim: Julian Assange offered pardon to "Lie" for Trump Current Events 20
Jesse3959 FE Claim Debunked: JTolan Epic Gravity Experiment - Flat earther disproves Perspective! (or his instruments.) Flat Earth 0
Wiggles Claim: Distant Objects Being Obscured Is Due To the "Mirror Blocking" Effect of Inferior Mirages Flat Earth 7
Mick West Claim: Section 13.1 on Vaccine Inserts Removed to Hide that Vaccines not Tested to Cause Cancer Conspiracy Theories 7
Rory Claim: footage of Great South Bay Bridge supports flat earth Flat Earth 11
mudr0 Claim: Australia was not visible from the moon for Apollo 11 Broadcasts Conspiracy Theories 7
Z.W. Wolf Claim: Moon Passing The Meridian Disproves Globe Earth Flat Earth 0
Z.W. Wolf Claim: Seeing The Same Stars All Year Disproves Globe Earth Flat Earth 20
Mick West Claim: Fertility Clinics are a new thing (David Icke) Conspiracy Theories 12
Rory Claim: Nasa' in Hebrew means "to deceive" Flat Earth 11
Leifer Claim: magnetic dust on cars proves chemtrail fallout Contrails and Chemtrails 11
Neil Obstat Claim: zooming in on setting sun proves flat earth Flat Earth 23
Marin B Claim: Passenger luggage limited to make room for chemical tanks Contrails and Chemtrails 15
MikeG Claim: DC officials are "flocking" to "Doomsday Camps" Conspiracy Theories 4
StarGazer Convex Earth Claim: Ships Disappear Below The Horizon Due To A Optical Phenomena Flat Earth 3
Nth Claim: 146 Mile Microwave Transmission Proves Flat Earth Flat Earth 26
FlightMuj Apollo 12 photo analysis shows Sun as bulb [claim] Conspiracy Theories 19
inkwell American Airlines Flight 77 Missing from Bureau of Transportation Departure Report 9/11 12
ConfusedHominid Need Debunking (Claim): Metabunk Curve Calculator Does Not Calculate for Angular Size Flat Earth 13
derwoodii Claim Melania Trump has a double, will the real 1st lady please stand up Conspiracy Theories 11
StarGazer Claim: First Image of Space Taken from V-2 Rocket Proves the Earth is Flat Flat Earth 17
Z.W. Wolf Claim: The Moon's Shadow During The Solar Eclipse Disproves Sphere Earth Flat Earth 97
Related Articles


















































Related Articles

Top