What else could it be if not the sky? And it's clearly not aircraft lights or anything of that sort.
I mean just look at this light:
It appears extremely fast. It couldn't be an aircraft. Could this be video editing? It looks fake to me.
Our Lady of Assuit Need Debunking
- Thread starter shawnfrye
- Start date
What else could it be if not the sky? And it's clearly not aircraft lights or anything of that sort.
I mean just look at this light:
It appears extremely fast. It couldn't be an aircraft. Could this be video editing? It looks fake to me.
It really doesn't. You have been provided an explanation. You may agree or disagree with it. If you think it is something please prove proof to support your claim as the Posting Guidelines require.
The fact that nobody can come up with a reasonable explanation is why it demands explanation.
How can this light which appears in half a second be an aircraft or whatever?
Fritzkquzerk
Senior Member
Unexplained or not explained thoroughly does not mean "extraordinary" or supernatural.
We just have a bunch of low quality photos of lights around a church.
If there were more videos, from more angles, then we could analyze them and come up with an explanation that can satisfy you.
But until then, there's not much to work on (photo quality is very low, info is scarce).
Are there other videos that we can see, or are we left with a bunch of ambiguous frames?
One thing that will surely not work around here is spamming the idea that since we cannot properly identify a light, then it means it's unexplainable under the current scientific paradigm.
So this light which appears for a half a second is possibly an aircraft light? Or a celestial body?
I'm sorry for being difficult. I just really want to put this to rest but this seems so compelling.
Possibly. Or possibly something else. There is little information to go on.
Fritzkquzerk
Senior Member
I'd wait for the Virgin to appear in front of a modern HI-res camera first.
Todd Feinman
Senior Member
Let me know when it happens! I have a bunch of questions for her….
NorCal Dave
Senior Member.
I don't think anybody is suggesting this particular thing is an aircraft, just that some of the lights that appear in various shots, could be aircraft.
As has been noted repeatedly there are a number of problems with this video related to explaining what's being seen.
First are the questions of provenience and provenance. Provenience refers to the exact origin or spot where something is discovered. In this case, it refers to the origin of the video: Who recorded this? When did they record it? Where were they? What equipment were they using? Provenance refers to the chain of custody of the video after it was created. What happened to the original video after it was created? Who had it? How did it end up in this YouTube post?
These are some of the first questions you should ask yourself when watching a video that claims to show something anomalous or supernatural. Who created this and where did it come from? People frequently keep this information hidden so as to make the video appear more mysterious and difficult to explain. For example, the time coded video allowed @Giddierone to show, even if the time stamp is a bit off, it's clear the mysterious light behind the church was just the moon.
As for this light you find compelling, it's part of a sequence that is mostly just black, with some occasional flashes of light. It seems to go from 4:24 to 4:42, so around 20 seconds. If you queue up to 4:24 on YouTube, you can use the < and > keys to scrub through the sequence 1 frame at a time. If you do that, you'll find most of it is just black. In some cases there are lights of some sort at the very extreme bottom of the screen:
Sometimes faint ghost images appear for a single frame:
And sometimes clearer images appear, again for a single frame:
However, note that the clearer images, again 1 frame each, are of different things:
It appears one attempted to create a sequence of a single camera recording a series of flashes, but the scene keeps changing. In the emiddle of all this is your odd shaped light:
Which appearsagain a number of frames later, in exactly the same spot:
It's just 2 random frames from a collection of random appearing frames. There is no context at all, aside from the other random frames proceeding and following it. Some of those frames that show parts of the church, each show different views, suggesting they are not related in time and space. The object you find compelling only appears as 1 frame, with the surrounding frames being completely black. This appears to be an edited sequence of random stuff that is unrelated.
Therefore we can draw no conclusion about what this object is or where it is. It's completely out of context and likely something mundane, rather than a spiritual manifestation of some sort.
FatPhil
Senior Member.
If what I said was meaningless, then perhaps the explanation was precisely as meaningless when you used exactly the same words earlier in the thread. If you don't even recognise your own arguments when they are repeated back to you, then perhaps you should pay more attention to the arguments you are making.
All the evidence shows is that there are lights in sight of a church, some of which are pointing at the camera, some of which are pointing at the church. There is nothing mysterious about any of this: we know lights exist, and can point in all directions.
You have presented nothing that "demands an explanation" beyond the mundane.
Similar threads
