Out of the Shadows by Jay Stratton, Is it worth reading?

tom.g

New Member
I don't think the book has been out all that long, but I have heard about it and have been lurking around searching here to see if anyone is debunking specific claims of evidence contained therein. What little elsewhere I have heard sounds rather preposterous and puts me off from reading it.

I am looking for opinions -- is it worth the time and money to acquire and read it?

I don't want to go merely by the raves on sites selling it....
 
Keyhoe_-_The_Flying_Saucers_Are_Real,_cover.png

Copyright 1950

In this explosive new book, former U.S. Marine Corps pilot Major Donald Keyhoe presents incontrovertible evidence gathered from Pentagon Insiders and scores of undeniably trustworthy eyewitness accounts that flying saucers are the products of unearthly intelligences, and that our government is suppressing the whole truth about this subject.





edwards.jpg

Copyright 1966

In this explosive new book, award winning investigative reporter Frank Edwards presents incontrovertible evidence gathered from Pentagon Insiders and scores of undeniably trustworthy eyewitness accounts that flying saucers are the products of unearthly intelligences, and that our government is suppressing the whole truth about this subject.





s-l1200.jpg

copyright 1987

In this explosive new book, noted UFO investigator Timothy Good presents incontrovertible evidence gathered from Pentagon Insiders and scores of undeniably trustworthy eyewitness accounts that flying saucers are the products of unearthly intelligences, and that several world governments are suppressing the whole truth about this subject.






shopping (2).png

copyright 2008

In this explosive new book, nuclear physicist Stanton Friedman presents incontrovertible evidence gathered from Pentagon Insiders and scores of undeniably trustworthy eyewitness accounts that flying saucers are the products of unearthly intelligences, and that several world governments are suppressing the whole truth about this subject.





Do you get my drift? There are more where these came from.
 
Last edited:
Just read through the 1-star and 2-star reviews on Amazon for this book, and a few of the 5-star reviews.
The 1&2-star reviews seem mostly to be from dedicated true-believers who are mad that the book did not tell them something they didn't already "know". To much autobiography and no new revelations, just rehashes of things already been said over the years.
The 5-star reviewers seem to be people who are less familiar with the UFO topic and for whom much of what he claims is new to them.
Not planning on buying.
 
is it worth the time and money to acquire and read it?
Depends on what you are looking for.
The book alternate between spooky stories at Stratton's house and the history of the AAWSAP to UAPTF push from Stratton's point of view. The spooky stories can be entertaining if that's something you like, the historical part is quite dry and boring but you learn who Stratton consider disclosure allies or legacy program assets in the governement and intelligence community.
There is no evidence of the existence of NHI or the Legacy Program in the book, only stories, most we already heard from different sources. There are a few evidences that Stratton and his buddies are bad at video and picture analysis though, since Stratton describe already debunked videos and pictures as evidence of NHI.
I personally wouldn't say it is worth reading unless you're really really interested in Stratton point of view, and even then I don't think it's worth paying 30 bucks for it.
 
The book alternate between spooky stories at Stratton's house and the history of the AAWSAP to UAPTF

That seems to be the standard layout for these books. Hunt for the Skinwalker and Skinwalkers at the Pentagon both follow a similar format. Alternating chapters about the historical workings of a program and UFO/paranormal anecdotes that justify the program. One wonders if there is some overlap in editors or maybe even ghost writers, but it seems to be a pretty standard format for these types of subjects.
 
I personally wouldn't say it is worth reading unless you're really really interested in Stratton point of view, and even then I don't think it's worth paying 30 bucks for it
I think it gives some interesting perspective on modern ufology, and the issues with magical thinking at the Pentagon. I can see how it would be disappointing to disclosure advocates who wanted some actual evidence. Things that seems to be "I saw alien bodies that the US gov recovered" turn out to me more like "I saw an alien looking through my son's bedroom window, also someone kept changing the thermostat and the kids say it wasn't them, so it must have been that alien"
 
personally I would rather this book RETOLD: What the UFO Books Get Right, Get Wrong, and Leave Out

External Quote:
@WoahVinnie read twenty of those books, from Jacques Vallee's seven volumes of journals to the newest memoirs by Luis Elizondo and Jay Stratton, and lined them up page against page
External Quote:
This isn't a debunking, and it isn't a sales pitch. It's a cross examination, with the receipts.
source: www.amazon.com/RETOLD-Books-Right-Wrong-Leave-ebook/dp/B0HPSFLVXB

I ordered it last Friday, the day of its launch. I'm not the most avid reader (I prefer audiobooks) but it certainly looks interesting and Ill try and report back maybe.
 
View attachment 94362
Copyright 1950

In this explosive new book, former U.S. Marine Corps pilot Major Donald Keyhoe presents incontrovertible evidence gathered from Pentagon Insiders and scores of undeniably trustworthy eyewitness accounts that flying saucers are the products of unearthly intelligences, and that our government is suppressing the whole truth about this subject.





View attachment 94363
Copyright 1966

In this explosive new book, award winning investigative reporter Frank Edwards presents incontrovertible evidence gathered from Pentagon Insiders and scores of undeniably trustworthy eyewitness accounts that flying saucers are the products of unearthly intelligences, and that our government is suppressing the whole truth about this subject.





View attachment 94365
copyright 1987

In this explosive new book, noted UFO investigator Timothy Good presents incontrovertible evidence gathered from Pentagon Insiders and scores of undeniably trustworthy eyewitness accounts that flying saucers are the products of unearthly intelligences, and that several world governments are suppressing the whole truth about this subject.






View attachment 94364
copyright 2008

In this explosive new book, nuclear physicist Stanton Friedman presents incontrovertible evidence gathered from Pentagon Insiders and scores of undeniably trustworthy eyewitness accounts that flying saucers are the products of unearthly intelligences, and that several world governments are suppressing the whole truth about this subject.





Do you get my drift? There are more where these came from.
I'm not really sure who the market is for books that explode (seems like that would make it difficult to read), but there are so many of them!
 
personally I would rather this book RETOLD: What the UFO Books Get Right, Get Wrong, and Leave Out

External Quote:
@WoahVinnie read twenty of those books, from Jacques Vallee's seven volumes of journals to the newest memoirs by Luis Elizondo and Jay Stratton, and lined them up page against page
External Quote:
This isn't a debunking, and it isn't a sales pitch. It's a cross examination, with the receipts.
source: www.amazon.com/RETOLD-Books-Right-Wrong-Leave-ebook/dp/B0HPSFLVXB

I ordered it last Friday, the day of its launch. I'm not the most avid reader (I prefer audiobooks) but it certainly looks interesting and Ill try and report back maybe.

For some reason I'm getting blocked from you links. However, I did find it on Amazon and at $5 for the Kindle version, it sounds very interesting:

External Quote:

RETOLD traces each claim back to the earliest page that records it and shows what changed with every telling. It covers AAWSAP and AATIP, Skinwalker Ranch, the Tic Tac, Bob Lazar, Roswell, MJ 12, Serpo and the disinformation campaigns around them. It gives credit where the books are careful and names the errors anyone can check.
Thanks for the heads up.
 
Back
Top