Case Analysis: Data: (Representation, Bases, Sheets, Maps, Mining) and Methodologies/Workflows)

David Esp

New Member
Just throwing this out there...

Is anyone (else) thinking about or looking into "Case Analysis: Data: (Representation, Bases, Sheets, Maps, Mining) and Methodologies/Workflows)" ? Any recommended OSINT apps/workflows?
Not expecting anyone to have all the answers, but how about we swap notes here?

What exists, or could be assembled, to improve the quality, productivity and pleasure of correlating information from multiple sources? Example source types include witness statements, interviews, talks, rumours, ideas. Is there anything to assist the correlation of such information in terms of one or more story "universes", eg each "universe" representing a different hypothesis and most likely differing in terms of timelines. Tools to simplify their comparison. Mega-DIFF.

What is a good and practical methodology/procedure/workflow and app (software/service) based solution to support such an approach? Integrated AI-based solutions tend to be prohibitively expensive. Can something sensible be assembled out of readily available (though possibly specialised or even open source) components (apps or coding libraries) ? Does such a project/solution already exist? Do other people (eg you) already do that? Without falling down an informal research & development rabbit-hole?

Some possible angles:
  • Big picture: OSINT Resources
  • Standard databases and spreadsheets (with dynamic macros/functions/computations/dependencies)
  • Specialised timeline-supporting apps/tools.
  • Hyper note supporting apps/services such as (geeky, advancing) ROAM and (popular-appeal, stable) Notion.
  • Witness statement notation systems (useful as shorthand and as possible input to dynamic display and reasoning systems)
  • Any related data standards (eg in XML).
  • Coding from scratch (eg in a simple/dynamic/flexible object-oriented programming language such as Smalltalk).
  • Audio (eg Podcast) and Video (eg YT) analysis/mark-up strategy/tools (eg CinePlay, ELAN, FCPX...)

Mick West

Staff member
I think in most cases there's not enough information to make it worth having a tool-set to analyze it. Two counter-examples might be the Nimitz UFO case, where there's a variety of events, differing accounts, and overlapping timelines, and then UFOs in general.

People sometimes think that setting up a database will give some useful information, but it often turns into a collection of junk. Take MUFON, for example. It's a clunky database (now semi-private) that contains multiple user stories and photos that have obvious explanations. If there are any gems in there, they get lost. Significant expert input and continued curation is required.

I think a timeline comparison tool might be useful, and I'm surprised there isn't such a thing.

David Esp

New Member
I wasn't proposing a MUFON-scale thing, just a kind of "smart documentation" process and tool to help cope with any investigation project involving multiple accounts (sometimes from the same witness at different times, maybe in different contexts) for a single incident/event (eg Nimitz, RFI). Also with a map or network to represent various kinds of association (ideally varying overt time eg years) between people.

For the latter purpose (associations mapping) have been considering CASOS ORA Lite, the repurposable Cytoscape and the more general-purpose yEd.

I once knocked up something in an AI language (Prolog) to help me get my head around the structure and details of an important complex engineering system (and made an earlier development in BASIC to help cope with house-buying legalese). But development takes time and in any case I wonder if anything better (and likely more standardised) now exists. At a reasonable cost!

Simplest for timelines would be to use tables (in databases or spreadsheets or even documents) where each column was a timeline. I have found various timeline representation/presentation apps but none so far that can be dynamically linked to a table (as above).

I wonder what other people do. Or where else to ask.

David Esp

New Member
Mick - In the Comments following your YT video debunking of internal reflection artefacts in a program on the History Channel, I discovered your recommendation of Kyle Polich, who is a data scientist working with AI (as I have also been). I will try asking him.
The relevant YT link: Source:

David Esp

New Member
Several diagrammatic systems exist to represent the structure and inference flow of reasoned arguments.

The following paper presents one such. My reference to that system is not intended as any kind of favourite or recommendation but purely as one particular and accessible example, to illustrate the kind of thing I have been considering (and am wondering if others have also, along with any supporting standards, software libraries or applications).

The paper:
“Using Computer-Aided Argument Mapping
to Teach Reasoning”, by Martin Davies, Ashley Barnett, and Tim van Gelder.
This paper states: “Argument mapping is a way of diagramming the logical structure of an argument to explicitly and concisely represent reasoning.”
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
ofu Travis Walton case: Crew boss confesses hoax UFOs and Aliens 3
jarlrmai MUFON case 115206 - [OBJECT] CROSSED OVER I-10 FREEWAY LEAVING A SHADOW OF ITS SHAPE/SIZE Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 15
Z.W. Wolf Was the New Guinea/Father Gill UFO Case a False Horizon? UFOs and Aliens 10
Mick West Solved: MUFON Case 105762 - White Cigar "Following" Plane near Zion Nation Park (United 541) Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 9
Dan Wilson The Monsanto and Dewayne Johnson Court Case Health and Quackery 13
Mick West Red Winged UFO, Mufon case 91964 - Plane Lights Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 34
Tom Binney Does my FE Debunk in this case make sense to you guys? Practical Debunking 23
Veronica! Any resources for debunking a 'cold case' UFO sighting? Practical Debunking 7
Balance Met Office - Case Study Contrail-induced Cirrus Contrails and Chemtrails 0
Bruno D. Chocolate Diet hoax - interesting case about junk science General Discussion 4
Chew MUFON Case #56393 UFOs and Aliens 4
Pete Tar Misrepresented Saudi rape case General Discussion 0
mynym The corporate media's representation of the Zimmerman case, debunked General Discussion 12
Jay Reynolds Debunked: Belfort Group "Case Orange" conclusions & recommendations Contrails and Chemtrails 568
SR1419 How the case against the MMR vaccine was fixed- Health and Quackery 9
Mick West The Case for Preemptive Debunking Practical Debunking 13
J Claim: Genomic analysis of SARS-CoV-2 shows that it already existed in other countries such as France, India, Netherlands, England and United States Coronavirus COVID-19 1
TopBunk Eyewitness variance in mass UFO/UAP sightings: a database. UFOs and Aliens 1
Mendel A Game Designer’s Analysis Of QAnon General Discussion 3
H Debunked: Dr. Shiva's Scatterplot Analysis of Michigan Precincts Election 2020 43
Mick West Hulsey UAF report DATA RELEASE: analysis thread 9/11 29
Mick West Sept 3, 2019 release of Hulsey's WTC7 draft report: Analysis 9/11 183
Oystein AE911Truth: Analysis of their Facebook "Likes" 9/11 27
Mick West Aliens vs. Golf Carts - Denbigh UFO Analysis UFOs and Aliens 10
B Bob Lazar 1989 Video Analysis Method UFOs and Aliens 1
Tony Szamboti Sound Analysis of Plasco Collapse 9/11 45
Mick West Debunked: AE911Truth's Analysis of Slag Residue from WTC Debris 9/11 20
FlightMuj Apollo 12 photo analysis shows Sun as bulb [claim] Conspiracy Theories 19
Mick West Debunking: A Meta-Analysis of the Psychological Efficacy of Messages Countering Misinformation Practical Debunking 5
T FE balloon video curvature analysis using Blender Flat Earth 4
Mick West Analysis: Crathes Castle "Ghost" in Doorway Photo Ghosts, Monsters, and the Paranormal 6
Sausalito Spectral analysis of alleged "chemtrails" Contrails and Chemtrails 1
TEEJ Bellingcat Analysis of Satellite Imagery Used In Russian Claims Against Ukraine Flight MH17 104
derwoodii ISIS suicide bomber's car explodes in mid air, needs analysis General Discussion 15
JFDee Germanwings Airbus Crash: Factual Analysis General Discussion 98
Mike Fl Can someone debunk this? Sandy Hook Shooting 100% Fraud Proof in 2 mins. - Photo Time Analysis Sandy Hook 21
Efftup Chemtrail additives in Jet fuel: a mathematical analysis Contrails and Chemtrails 23
L Photos of trails over Switzerland [back to the 1970s] and Chemical Analysis of Jacuzzi Cover Water Contrails and Chemtrails 18
C 9/11 P4T FDR analysis of flight 77 9/11 26
jaydeehess Why little to no analysis of steel from WTC7? 9/11 45
Leifer debunked: "Analysis Finds Monsanto’s GM Corn Nutritionally Dead, Highly Toxic " Science and Pseudoscience 0
MikeC More analysis of "rainwater" - New Zealand Contrails and Chemtrails 89
Jay Reynolds Hair Analysis – It’s Lack of Utility Contrails and Chemtrails 1
Spongebob New analysis of 9/11 radar and video evidence 9/11 6
hemi NZ soil/rainwater analysis Contrails and Chemtrails 6
Des O Chemtrail Analysis Project Contrails and Chemtrails 15
Mick West How to Delete Your Account and Data on Metabunk How To 0
G Claim: China refused to hand "key data" to WHO delegation during the recent investigation in Wuhan Coronavirus COVID-19 29
Mick West Analyzing Georgia Runoff NYT (and other) Data Election 2020 19
Z.W. Wolf Explained: Red Mirages, Blue Shifts, and Data Dumps in the 2020 Election Election 2020 21
Related Articles

Related Articles