From Villarroel, Streblyanska, Bruehl and Geier's "A Response to paper Critical Evaluation of Studies...", https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.15171,
usefully quoted by @NorCal Dave, post #865, my emphasis:
Finally, the analysis demonstrating that being...
I'm not sure much can be done with this, as it's nearly 20 years old. Even if one wanted to try and replicate it, how? These old cameras can be found for $50-$150 here in the US. While this particular model was introduced in 2005, the underlying...
There's another self-correlative effect in that -- the POSS-1 shots and UFO sightings roughly track with the weather. That is, you can't photograph the sky when it's cloudy; people don't see UFOs in the sky (or planets or bright stars) when it's...
There's another self-correlative effect in that -- the POSS-1 shots and UFO sightings roughly track with the weather. That is, you can't photograph the sky when it's cloudy; people don't see UFOs in the sky (or planets or bright stars) when it's...
There's another self-correlative effect in that -- the POSS-1 shots and UFO sightings roughly track with the weather. That is, you can't photograph the sky when it's cloudy; people don't see UFOs in the sky (or planets or bright stars) when it's...
From Villarroel, Streblyanska, Bruehl and Geier's "A Response to paper Critical Evaluation of Studies...", https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.15171,
usefully quoted by @NorCal Dave, post #865, my emphasis:
Finally, the analysis demonstrating that being...
From Villarroel, Streblyanska, Bruehl and Geier's "A Response to paper Critical Evaluation of Studies...", https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.15171,
usefully quoted by @NorCal Dave, post #865, my emphasis:
Finally, the analysis demonstrating that being...
From Villarroel, Streblyanska, Bruehl and Geier's "A Response to paper Critical Evaluation of Studies...", https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.15171,
usefully quoted by @NorCal Dave, post #865, my emphasis:
Finally, the analysis demonstrating that being...
I did yet another analysis, this time about the differences of two full plate scans: IRSA (the ones I'm using) and STScI (the ones suggested by Villarroel). See...
This appears to be their critique of Watters relevant to the nuke paper in the OP:
The next issue concerns the temporal correlations with nuclear weapon tests and UAP in Bruehl & Villarroel (2025). The critique by Watters et al. (2026) (Section...
Quote below from "A study claimed UFOs orbited Earth in the 1950s. Then scientists checked the math", Adam Frank, Big Think, August 27, 2026 as per @Smythe Bacchus' post #851. Frank's article discusses "Critical Evaluation of Studies Alleging...
Reply is here maybe?:
https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.15171
We respond to the critique by Watters et al. (2026) of the statistical analyses in Villarroel et al. (2025) and Bruehl & Villarroel (2025). We argue that the critique conflates...
New preprint: Microscopy assessment of two multiple-transient candidates, Jun Yang & Beatriz Villarroel. Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.26371 (submitted 26 Aug 2026). PDF version is attached.
Short summary: the paper physically re-examines two...
"Paper-parity" run has completed. Report and data: https://github.com/jannefi/poss1-plate-slice/blob/main/results/s0-642-paper-parity-20260828/README.md
This release does not replace or change anything I released previously. It's a separate...