Latest activity

Members online

  • D
    Don Kielty reacted to John J.'s post in the thread Our Lady of Assuit Need Debunking with Informative Informative.
    Possibly birds. Pigeons and doves are common in Egypt, large flocks live in cities and they are also reared for food and sporting purposes, and for their guano which is a source of agricultural fertilizer, "Pigeons in Egypt: A Cultural and...
  • Landru
    Landru reacted to Giddierone's post in the thread Our Lady of Assuit Need Debunking with Like Like.
    Here's a Sitrec. It's 100% the moon. You can scrub the time forward from 2:03 to 2:26 (and beyond) and see how the moon moves in the sky. This lines up exactly with the video stills...
  • Giddierone
    Here's a Sitrec. It's 100% the moon. You can scrub the time forward from 2:03 to 2:26 (and beyond) and see how the moon moves in the sky. This lines up exactly with the video stills...
  • Mauro
    Mauro reacted to John J.'s post in the thread Our Lady of Assuit Need Debunking with Like Like.
    (It would be useful if you could provide a link to claims). I would perhaps ask, (1) How do you distinguish between something being luminous and something reflecting light? (2) Where is the evidence? Many Egyptians would have had cameras...
  • Mauro
    Mauro reacted to Ann K's post in the thread Our Lady of Assuit Need Debunking with Agree Agree.
    Illuminated birds look brilliant against a black sky. People exaggerate. Religiously extreme people exaggerate a lot, or choose from a different set of words than most people would use.
  • FatPhil
    FatPhil reacted to Landru's post in the thread Our Lady of Assuit Need Debunking with Like Like.
    That is not the standard here. No one has to explain something to your satisfaction. Do you have evidence to support whatever claim you're making?
  • FatPhil
    FatPhil reacted to shawnfrye's post in the thread Our Lady of Assuit Need Debunking with Dislike Dislike.
    But like half of the testimonies I’ve seen mention them being bright. I don’t know if exaggeration is gonna cut it.
  • FatPhil
    Things in the dark that reflect bright light can be described as luminous. This is starting to look a bit gish-gallopy.
  • MonkeeSage
    MonkeeSage reacted to JMartJr's post in the thread Our Lady of Assuit Need Debunking with Like Like.
    White or light-clored birds with a light shining on them from below, seen against a dark sky background. will look luminous -- they are, after all, being illuminated. Here are some probably-gulls over the Luxor in Vegas... This would work for...
Back
Top