Latest activity
What's new
-
John J. reacted to NoParty's post in the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran with
Agree.
I'm not asking for anything like that. But saying you don't know what happened (when you almost certainly did, on day 1) erodes trust... -
Mendel reacted to NoParty's post in the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran with
Like.
I'm not asking for anything like that. But saying you don't know what happened (when you almost certainly did, on day 1) erodes trust... -
Mendel replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.well, I looked at the two failed fact checks, and they're minor with respect to what Fox news does. One was using a photo showing a muslim family fleeing from anti-muslim violence in 1947 India that wasn't taken where the unrest that the article...
-
deirdre replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.as if your trust could be more eroded. i think most people know we dont get answers to this stuff quickly, esp without video footage etc. add: they may know which missile dropped but they are going to want to investigate the chain of "how... -
deirdre replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.i know. i'm talking about your question. you seem to think that al jazeera and unesco are just using sloppy wording, right? i think they mean they think the school was targeted deliberately knowing it was a school. thats the opinion of which...
-
John J. reacted to deirdre's post in the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran with Agree.
i dont think people want the government to name names, they just want " we mistakenly bombed the school as our intel had it marked as a bunker with weapons of mass destruction" < that's my way of saying that sometimes intel get things wrong.
-
deirdre replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.i dont think people want the government to name names, they just want " we mistakenly bombed the school as our intel had it marked as a bunker with weapons of mass destruction" < that's my way of saying that sometimes intel get things wrong.
-
Mendel replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.Yes. And the Poynter people found that, sometimes, Al Jazeera doesn't.
-
John J. replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.My opinions on the Minab school bombing are that it was a tragic accident or act of negligence. I don't believe that there was a deliberate plan to murder schoolgirls. It is highly likely that either US or Israeli forces were responsible. I...
-
deirdre replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.do you have any idea how many children are killed and/or murdered around the world who receive "inadequate coverage"? Finding out the U.S made the mistake is not going to magically bring those children and teachers back to life. The media...
-
John J. replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.I'd agree that both the US and Israeli governments are almost certainly aware of which units (probably which specific aircraft) are responsible. Revealing those facts might not be operationally sensible. Suppose an airman/ woman of the same...
-
deirdre replied to the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran.yea i dont care a about a separate issue, i'm trying to understand your original question. the examples No Party and i gave were specifically about the school bombing, not the military operation in general. but i acknowledge we have differing...
-
Hi. I'm here to document the UFO craze. Maybe even write a book length post on ol' Ross Coulthart's career.
-
Mendel replied to the thread Welcome Thread - New Members Post Here.https://www.metabunk.org/threads/ross-coulthart.13159/ is the thread for that post. Welcome!
-
Ann K reacted to Gary C's post in the thread The Bombing of the Shajareh Tayyebeh Girls School in Minab, Iran with Like.
No. He's pointing out the likely intentional failure of coverage to distinguish between "intentionally/deliberately" bombing a building and "intentionally/deliberately" bombing a girl's school. Al Jazeera for example could have made that clear...