1. chuckbert

    chuckbert New Member

    Yup. Your final paragraph is kind of where I was heading. To perform an experiment you need a prior agreement to what the hypothesis, parameters and analysis are. If the experiment has been done previously anyway then it literally is no-win, and a bit like the offers to participate in a "debate", there is only one likely outcome. That is unless there is an experiment that can on their terms, within their parameters disprove their hypothesis. Which there isn't. :)

    Education is the answer, but retrospective eduction is a tough one and requires time and care, such as that which this place provides.
     
  2. Hama Neggs

    Hama Neggs Senior Member

    Two questions they steadfastly refuse to answer.
     
  3. Hama Neggs

    Hama Neggs Senior Member

    If you're going to test random air, why bother even getting to altitude? (Since they think the stuff wafts right to the ground, anyway)
     
  4. Mick West

    Mick West Administrator Staff Member

    "They" don't all think the same thing. Testing at altitude in a contrail would reveal any super-high concentration.

    Of course the concentration needed is likely impossible high (like the air would be solid aluminum). But I still view this more as a thought experiment. If they actually take it seriously they would need to think about more than just "is there any aluminum in the air", but "If we measure X ppb aluminum in the air, and we expected Y, then we hypothesize that this comes from trails sprayed at concentration Z".

    Now if they are going to spend $10,000 on testing, then you'd think that most people would actually do a little math and science beforehand to determine X, Y and Z. Preferably asking a few science-minded people to check the math.

    In fact, I would not be surprised if people have done the math, and decided it's a fools errand. Which is why we just hear talk about it.
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  5. Leifer

    Leifer Senior Member

    An experiment forced upon me....that cabin air does come from outside the aircraft...

    I flew to San Fransisco during the recent Camp fire. We descended into SFO airport, and as soon as we flew through the smokey layer of air from the fire, it smelled of forest fire inside the passenger cabin.
     
    • Informative Informative x 1