Unusual Multiple Halo over San Francisco [Pyramidal Ice Crystals - "Odd Radius Halos"]

skephu

Senior Member.
Patrick Roddie of San Francisco has posted this video showing a strange double halo:




What is this? I can't find anything like that in the atmospheric optics resources.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

skephu

Senior Member.
Here's a heavily color-enhanced version:
upload_2016-2-25_2-19-23.png

I think the inner, smaller ring (or rings) may be a corona. But the two outer rings seem to be too large for that, their edges are too sharp for a corona (and the spacings and the colors don't match a corona either). One of the outer rings must be the 22-degree halo, but what's the other one? It looks like the 22-deg halo repeated. Their inner edges are reddish, as it should be for the 22-deg halo.
 

SR1419

Senior Member.
Patrick Roddie has posted this video showing a strange double halo


he seems to conflate sundogs and halos- whilst related they are not the same thing...when I posted that they are not particularly rare- especially in winter, he deleted my post. I also asked if he really thought aluminum refracted light :)
 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
Comparing to an actual 22° halo from one of Roddie's excellent time-lapses(on the left, and a section over the top right), from the same viewpoint. The indicate ring does match a 22° halo. EDIT: This seems to be inaccurate, due to camera distortion .



The time-lapse lens is a bit fisheye, so the buildings don't line up exactly.
 
Last edited:

skephu

Senior Member.
Great, so the inner of the outer rings is the 22-degree halo. Then we have an extra ring. It's the "27-degree halo" or something :)
 

skephu

Senior Member.
Look at what I found searching for 28-degree halos:
Andrew J. Weinheimer and Charles A. Knight: Scheiner's Halo: Cubic Ice or Polycrystalline Hexagonal Ice?
J. Atmos. Sci., 44, 3304–3308.
A more recent description on an unlikely web site:
Now if this thing has only been reported 7 times in the last 350 years, and Patrick Roddie observed it then he can really say it is incredibly rare!

Could it really be a Scheiner's halo along with a 22-degree halo along with a corona? If yes, that's really an extraordinary phenomenon.
 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
Awesome! It looks like it is actually an additional halo, made with cubic ice! Check out the colors here.

https://www.wunderground.com/wximage/Skyywatcher88/111

 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
I wonder if the inner small ring is actually an artifact of Scheiner's halo, an addition small inner halo that's not normally well observed unless the sun is occluded.
 

skephu

Senior Member.
I just found this: World Database of rare halos
From this page it turns out that there are lots of halos:
6, 9, 12, 18, 20, 23, 24, 28, 35-degree halos.
Unfortunately most of the image links are dead on that page.
So the smaller inner rings may also be halos rather than a corona.
 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
More images and comments
http://spaceweathergallery.com/indi...d=123036&PHPSESSID=nr8hai2s5q7draeqte84h2t6k6


Last seen 1974. Now that's "incredibly rare".
 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
Of course with so many halos, it becomes harder to argue that it's all just ice crystals.

Well, except that this is unlikely to be seen again in the next several years. So unless chemtrails have only been sprayed on this one day, then it's all ice crystals.

And of course these halos are explained by ice crystals, just odd shaped ones.
 

Spectrar Ghost

Senior Member.
Well, except that this is unlikely to be seen again in the next several years. So unless chemtrails have only been sprayed on this one day, then it's all ice crystals.

And of course these halos are explained by ice crystals, just odd shaped ones.

This is where I really get hung up on 'chemtrails'. By choosing to ignore the science, one misses out on the truly strange and beautiful parts of meteorology.

The real explanations of phenomena like this are so much more interesting than arguing over pylon drains and ballast barrels.
 

Dan Page

Senior Member.
This phenomena was unusual enough to make it into todays www.spaceweather.com and explained as "tiny pyramids of ice", so it looks like you all were mostly spot on, and again the chemmies are a little off the mark.
 

skephu

Senior Member.
"On Mila's image I can see a bright 9 degree ring, an 18 degree one and then a clump of twenty-something radius halos."
That's a different assessment from what we arrived at. From Mick's comparison with an earlier photo by Patrick Roddie, we found that the inner outer ring is the 22° halo, and in that case the outer one must be at 28°. But if Les Cowley is right then the inner one is at 18° and the outer one should be the 22°.

If we take into account the very faint outermost ring here:
upload_2016-2-25_11-44-14.png

and we assume that it's at 35° then Les Cowley's assessment is right. But maybe it is the 46° halo, and then our assessment may be the correct one.

Hard to decide with such a large choice of possible halos.
 

Pete Tar

Senior Member.
Okay, I finally have to ask.
Circles are 360 degrees, so how can there be a 22 degree circle? The definition for the sun halo says it's 22 degrees from the sun, but it surrounds the sun completely, so what does that actually mean? I get it seems to be referring to distance from the center, but don't understand how it's measured or why it's expressed as a degree.
 

Trailblazer

Moderator
Staff member
Okay, I finally have to ask.
Circles are 360 degrees, so how can there be a 22 degree circle? The definition for the sun halo says it's 22 degrees from the sun, but it surrounds the sun completely, so what does that actually mean? I get it seems to be referring to distance from the center, but don't understand how it's measured or why it's expressed as a degree.
As @skephu says, it is a measure of the diameter (or radius, in this case). If you don't know the distance of an object (or, as in this case, it is not a physical object) then the only way you can express its size is in degrees: the amount of the field of view that it occupies.

If there are photos of these haloes taken using a known camera and lens, then it would be possible to determine which halo is which by comparing the apparent diameter to the known field of view. (For instance, anyone with an iPhone 5 who has tried to photograph a 22-degree halo, which is 43.1 to 44.7 degrees in diameter, red to blue, will have found that you can't quite fit the whole thing in, because the field of view along the short side of the camera is only about 43.8 degrees.)
 

Trailblazer

Moderator
Staff member
No. A rainbow is at ~41 degrees from the anti-solar point, so it would be a 180-41 = 139-degree halo.

A 180 degree halo would be a straight line :)

Well, kind of. It would be a line bisecting the sky between the sun and the point opposite the sun. At sunset or sunrise it would pass directly overhead.
 

Trailspotter

Senior Member.
Fascinating. He also posted this photo:
The photo has been taken from the roof of the building listed as his address. Adding it to Google Earth also matches the Sun position, suggesting that the photo was taken shortly before it was posted on Facebook at 2:54 PM EST.
Scheiner's Halo GE.jpg
Also, the resulting horizontal field of view of 83° is consistent with the inner halos being 9°, 18° etc. This is corroborated by a flickr photo, the horizontal field of which deduced from Exif is about 60°:
24932625480_c6d1fbc6c0_o.jpg
 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
That's a different assessment from what we arrived at. From Mick's comparison with an earlier photo by Patrick Roddie, we found that the inner outer ring is the 22° halo, and in that case the outer one must be at 28°. But if Les Cowley is right then the inner one is at 18° and the outer one should be the 22°.

My comparison might be a bit off, the non-rectilinear lens used for the time-lapse (note the curved sides of buildings) might be distorting things more than I thought.
 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
Luckily Patrick has quite a collection of photos from similar locations.

A 22° halo
12111940_10156679680075595_2028457170709587122_n.jpg

The multi-halo in a similar location, and more importantly with what seems to be the same camera/zoom. The top of the middle building is the same size in both shots. Time reported as 10:45AM

12743971_10156672421335595_5499361487246481662_n.jpg

Overlaying them with no scaling shows that the 22° halo more closely matches the outer halo

 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
OK, so then the outer ring is not Scheiner's halo after all. That's better because Scheiner's is too rare.

Yes, I've removed "Scheiner's" from the thread title. It's still a very interesting and unusual halo display though.
 
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
ECWXtreme Unusual vapour-looking "ghost" photograph. UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 3
Rory Unusual line of lights seen over Baja California Sur, Mexico Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 4
Mick West Unusual Light Track in Long Exposures, Grand Canyon Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 38
Trailblazer Unusual distrail? Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 15
cloudspotter Unusual Contrail Off Norway Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 15
Trailblazer Unusual contrail in Australia Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 1
Mick West Unusual Trail on the Russian Su-24 shot down By Turkey Contrails and Chemtrails 3
Mick West An unusual persistent aerodynamic contrail Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 11
Trailblazer Unusual flight paths over SW England Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 12
Efftup Circular Contrails over Dorset? [Likely military exercise] Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 44
Mick West Unusual Segment of Trail on KLAS-TV, Alamo, Las Vegas Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 4
Mick West Debunked: Government Stockpiling Unusual Amounts of Ammo [by Tom Coburn's GAO Report] Conspiracy Theories 63
U Unusual trails and clouds in Australia Contrails and Chemtrails 47
Mick West Multiple UFOs Fly Across Moon- Birds? Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 17
Dick Holman How many people follow multiple conspiracy theories? Practical Debunking 12
Mick West Multiple Parallel Trails over Reno, Nevada [KC-10 and F-16s] Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 0
Trailspotter Multiple parallel contrails near Canberra Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 5
Mick West "Fireballs" in the Sky over Davison [Multiple Sunlit Contrails] Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 3
D Can someone please explain this video of multiple trails? Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 28
FuzzyUK Multiple Infant Vaccines Linked To Dramatically Increased Mortality Health and Quackery 4
Mick West How Rare (or Common) are Haloes, Sun Dogs, etc? A Review of the Literature Contrails and Chemtrails 10
I Dark arc associated with cirrus ice cloud Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 6
Brandon The Kopp-Etchells Effect (Helicopter Light Scintillation Halo) Contrails and Chemtrails 23
CbIncus Errors in Cliff Carnicom's Halo Measurements? Contrails and Chemtrails 16
Leifer HALO jumping to collect contrail exhaust Contrails and Chemtrails 14
Mick West Debunked: Mile High Halo over Bronco's Stadium, Tim Tebow UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 1
Related Articles


























Related Articles

Top