Debunked: The Irish Slave Trade /The Slaves That Time Forgot

Summary: Starting in the 17th Century, a whole lot of Irish people were sent to America and nearby islands, often against their will, and served as indentured servents, frequently under harsh conditions. The claim has been made that they were "slaves", that their treatment was more harsh than that of African slaves, and that there were vast numbers of them. This claim has fueled many popular memes which imply that white slave descendents have shrugged off their history of oppression, while black slave descendents are still asking for handouts.

Liam Hogan has done a spectacular job of debunking the many exaggerations that are part of this claim.

A few details and links:

The article currently making the rounds on social media is The Irish Slave Trade – The Forgotten “White” Slaves, by John Martin. (This was published on 3/17/15 by GlobalResearch, with a deceptive image of a book that is not the source of Martin's information. The article itself actually dates from 4/13/08, when it was published under the title The Slaves That Time Forgot.) Martin makes a number of claims without providing any sources -- for example:

John Martin appears to have taken all his information from a much longer article, Irish slaves in the Caribbean, by James F. Cavanaugh, published on the Kavanagh/Cavanaugh Family genealogical website. Again, Cavanaugh provides no sources for his claims, which are nearly identical but more extensive than those in Martin's article (except that only 132 slaves got dumped overboard instead of 1302!).

How believable is this? Not very, it turns out. Liam Hogan has written a series of 6 articles (with more to follow) which dissect the memes and the underlying claims:

Part 1: Debunking the imagery of the “Irish slaves” meme
This looks at 25 images used in Irish slavery memes, and identifies the source of the image. Some of the photos of alleged Irish slaves are actually 20th Century child laborers, black men being beaten, Amazonian Indians, Andersonville prison victims, etc.

Part 2: How the African victims of the Zong Massacre were replaced with “Irish slaves”
How the murder of 132 to 142 African slaves transmogrified into the murder of 132 or 1302 Irish slaves.

Part 3: The “Forced Breeding” myth in the “Irish slaves” meme
No evidence that it happened, lots of evidence that it was unlikely, and one famous case of a Irish free woman who married a black slave out of love.

Part 4: A review of the numbers in the “Irish slaves” meme
Carefully examines all the numbers and statistics and dates in John Martin's paper. In some cases, he finds an actual source for Martin's numbers to demonstrate the screwiness thereof. For example, the claim of 300,000 Irish slaves, for which there is no evidence, appears to come from a blurb on the back cover of White Cargo: The Forgotten History of Britain’s White Slaves in America, by Don Jordan and Michael Walsh, which is about all the white servants sent by the British, not just the Irish ones. This back-cover blurb, in turn, seems to come from this short passage in the book:
Part 5: Exaggeration and the appropriation of the torture of enslaved Africans in the “Irish slaves” meme
Traces claims about abuse of Irish indentured servants. Some abuse incidents were real but extraordinary; others are actually stories of abuses committed against black slaves.

Part 6: The Myth of Colonel William Brayne and the “Irish slaves”
I cannot say enough good things about this piece of scholarship. In 1657, the military governor of Jamaica requested that the British send servants (voluntary or involuntary) to help the struggling all-military colony, and promised that "if servants were sent, they that have interest in them will be more carefull of them, and worke them moderately, by which many more lives would be saved, and plantations more forwarded." Hogan shows how this quote was distorted in a 1774 book, and further distorted in an 1828 book, and yet further in 1873, and 1883, and 1926, and 1993, and finally in 2003 by James Cavanaugh in the article that was Martin's source. By this point, it now read:
This article is an exceptional piece of debunking scholarship. Included in an appendix are numerous primary sources (letters sent by Jamaican authorities).

Anyway, I'm posting this here to give Liam Hogan's work a bit more well-deserved publicity, but also because it's such a very good example of how to do debunking.
 

Whitebeard

Senior Member.
Very interesting and informative and nice debunking. But it must be remembered that prior to the establishment of the African slave trade, most of the labour on English / British plantations in the Americas was provided by convicts and indentured labour from England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland. And whilst these sentences of transportation were in theory for a set number of years, 7 or 10 being the norm, the need to work off the debt these convicts accrued whilst serving their sentences, (remember in British prisons at the time the convict was expected to pay for his own food and lodge - transported convicts were expected to do the same). Therefore on 'release' a prisoner was oft faced with a huge debt, that in all reality could only be repaid via indentured labour, more often than not in conditions that bore little difference to those of the African slaves that were to follow.

What makes this period in UK history even more shameful is the way these convicts were obtained. In the 1660's Bristol merchants who owned plantations in the Americas were so short of labour the local 'charlies' (watchmen provided by the local corporation to police the city) were arresting every vagrant, petty thief and drunk they could and the local magistrates were convicting the lot with 7 years transportation to the Americas (source). And Bristol wasn't alone in this practice, Liverpool, Southampton, London, Dublin and many other places in Britain were doing the same. It is estimated that between 1600 and 1750 around 100,000 convicts left the British Isles for the new world, and the number of willing indentured labourers (often forced into it by poverty and starvation) was several times that number.

This 'white slave trade' ended in the 1770's for the following reasons. 1) The growth of the African slave trade was providing larger numbers of workers at a lower cost. 2) Legal and penal reform in Britain made it harder for plantation owners to obtain the convicts. 3) The growth of the American revolutionary zeal made the authorities afraid that transported convicts would escape and join the revolution against British rule. and 4) The discovery and settlement of Australia gave the British a new land to settle and somewhere else to send their convicts.

However indentured labour in the West Indies did continue through to the 1850's, fueled as it was but continued poverty and events such as the Irish Potato Famine, and given the English traditional contempt of the Irish lower classes at the time, did mean that these labourers were treated very badly. However Hogan is right to make the distinction between indentured labour and chattel labour and his full essay does make very interesting and informative reading.

Liam Hogans Essay in full
https://www.academia.edu/9475964/The_Myth_of_Irish_Slaves_in_the_Colonies
 
Thanks for that informative post, Whitebeard. I think it's important to keep an accurate balance. There's no doubt the Irish were badly abused, and I'm sure there were many cases where their situation was indistinguishable from slavery (except that their children did not automatically become slaves too). It seems to be an unfortunate trait of humans that some of us will try to make slaves of others of us, or as close to slaves as current laws and customs allow.

It's also unfortunate that these events of centuries ago are being distorted today to support one political viewpoint or another -- and it does go both ways.

Exaggerating the number of Irish indentured servants, the fraction of them who were effectively slaves, and the harshness of their treatment, supports the narrative that many peoples have suffered similar oppression in the past, yet somehow Irish-American whites were able to make something of themselves, while African-American blacks still claim to be victims deserving handouts. Obviously this view is popular among anti-black racists, but it's not inherently a racist concept -- it's also shared by many non-racist conservatives and libertarians who believe people should take responsibility for themselves and not depend on governmental wealth-redistribution.

On the other hand, minimizing and overlooking the treatment of the Irish also supports some biased narratives. It fits with the trivialized history we were taught in elementary school in the 1960s, that the English were the very civilized source of American civilization, and indentured servitude was merely a challenging way to pay for your ship fare. Today, it also fits with the concept that all whites have always had an easy life at the expense of blacks and other races, and therefore all whites are responsible for the oppression and poverty of non-whites. Again, this is not inherently a racist concept. But it's wrong to distort history just to support it.
 
Snopes posted an article about this issue today:

Slave to the Facts

 
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
Rory Debunked: UK undertaker's claim that Covid vaccine is responsible for spike in deaths Coronavirus COVID-19 0
Marc Powell Debunked: 9/11 truth experts are knowledgeable professionals and their judgments are to be trusted 9/11 195
Marc Powell Debunked: Explosions preparatory to demolition of the WTC North Tower are visible as Flight 175 crashes into the South Tower 9/11 7
Mick West Debunked: Pfizer Developing a Twice-Per-Day COVID Pill, Taken Alongside Vaccines Coronavirus COVID-19 0
Marc Powell Debunked: Demolition “squib” is visible at top of WTC North Tower before Flight 11 crash 9/11 62
Marc Powell Debunked: Construction worker Philip Morelli experienced an explosion in the sub-basement of the North Tower 9/11 0
Marc Powell Debunked: ABC News correspondent George Stephanopoulos reported an explosion in the subway 9/11 1
Marc Powell Debunked: Debris from twin towers was projected upward by explosives 9/11 13
Marc Powell Debunked: Government officials revealed having foreknowledge of Building 7’s collapse 9/11 58
Marc Powell Debunked: NIST computer simulation of Building 7 collapse is inaccurate 9/11 22
Marc Powell Debunked: FEMA reported finding evidence that steel had melted. 9/11 47
Marc Powell Debunked: VP Dick Cheney ordered a standdown of jet fighters on 9/11 9/11 16
Oystein Debunked: Claim that Bobby McIlvaine's injuries ("lacerations") are best explained as result of glass shards and debris from bombs 9/11 22
Marc Powell Debunked: World Trade Center should not have collapsed due to 9/11 fires 9/11 3
Marc Powell Debunked: Firefighter reports of secondary explosions 9/11 3
Marc Powell Debunked: Steel was hurled hundreds of feet by explosives 9/11 4
Marc Powell Debunked: Demolition Explosion Before Collapse of South Tower 9/11 8
Marc Powell Debunked: Explosion in South Tower Lobby 9/11 7
Marc Powell Debunked: Mysterious Explosion Before the Flight 11 Crash 9/11 48
J.d.K Debunked: Marx: "The classes and the races too weak to master the new conditions must give way... They must perish in the revolutionary Holocaust" Quotes Debunked 0
dimebag2 Poll : Which DOD Navy video do you consider debunked ? UFO Videos and Reports from the US Navy 74
Mick West Debunked: Diving Triangle UFO Photos from Reddit [Fake] UFOs and Aliens 37
Theferäl [Debunked] Object Seen From Airplane Above Canberra: 04 Apr 2012 Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 5
TEEJ Debunked: Claim that Joe Biden's hand passes through microphone during White House press gaggle, 16th March 2021 Election 2020 8
bird_up Debunked: "Interdimensional being" caught on CCTV in Neza, Mexico Ghosts, Monsters, and the Paranormal 6
M Debunked: Atmospheric pressure on Mars is 9 PSI, not 0.09 PSI as claimed by NASA Science and Pseudoscience 75
Patrick Gonzalez Debunked: missing cable on Perseverance landing footage proves it is fake. General Discussion 3
TEEJ Debunked: Biden's Oval Office "Coming Apart at the Seams" [It's a Door] Election 2020 19
derrick06 Debunked: UFO over California Highway (TMZ) UFOs and Aliens 1
P Debunked: 7 Alleged photos of aliens UFOs and Aliens 9
Mick West Debunked: Biden signing "Blank" Executive Orders Election 2020 5
Mick West Debunked: Biden in "Fake" Oval Office Election 2020 27
P Debunked: UN hidden camera: the first UFO contact happened [Deep Fake] UFOs and Aliens 3
Mick West Debunked: 94% of Fulton County Ballots Manually Adjudicated [It's a Process all Batches go Through] Election 2020 0
Mick West Debunked: "Missile Strike" caused Nashville Explosion General Discussion 3
Mick West Debunked: Nashville Explosion was "Across the Street" from the RV General Discussion 0
Mick West Debunked: "Error rate of 68.5% Allowable is .0008%" [Neither is True] Election 2020 4
Mick West Debunked: Claim that the Electoral College Count On Jan 6 will Change the Election Election 2020 136
Rory Debunked: Einstein wrote "blind belief in authority is the greatest enemy of truth" Quotes Debunked 12
Mick West Debunked: Navid Keshavarz-Nia's Claims of "A Sudden Rise in Slope" as Election Fraud Evidence Election 2020 5
Mick West Debunked: Trump's Claim of "1,126,940 votes created out of thin air" in PA Election 2020 9
Mick West Debunked: Crowder's "Fraud Week" Title Graphic (and Why it Matters) Election 2020 1
JFDee Debunked: Democratic senators complained about 'vote switching' by Dominion voting machines in 2019 Election 2020 2
Mendel Debunked: The Democrats are trying to take away freedom of religion Election 2020 6
H Debunked: Dr. Shiva's Scatterplot Analysis of Michigan Precincts Election 2020 43
Mick West Debunked: Suspicious "Biden Only" Ballots in Georgia Election 2020 3
Mick West Debunked: "Nancy Pelosi's long time Chief of Staff is a key executive at Dominion Voting" Election 2020 0
Mick West Debunked: Wisconsin Turnout 89% Impossible High [Actually 72%] Election 2020 1
Mick West Debunked: Video of Poll Worker "Filling In" Ballots. Election 2020 3
Mick West Debunked: Pentagon has Evidence of "Off-World Vehicles Not Made on this Earth" UFO Videos and Reports from the US Navy 14
Related Articles


















































Related Articles

Top