Debunked: Pollock vs Farmers Loan, 16th amendment and illegal taxes

MikeC

Closed Account
Pollock vs Farmers Loan Trust Co is a case that "tax protestors" of various ilks like to quote to prove that some or all taxes are illegal.

A 2nd related issue they like to bring up in this regard is the 16th amendment which they claim is illegal because it was not properly ratified.

Pollock is a fairly simple case - the Wilson-Gorman Tariff Act of 1894 made provision for taxation of income from various sources - including rent, interest and dividends. These 3 were held to be direct taxes, and therefore had to be apportioned in accordance with population - Article I, Section 9 Clause 4 of the constitution states:

This means that direct taxes can only be levied in proportion to population - the Wilson-Gorman Tarrif Act had tried to tax these 3 types of income as indirect taxes without apportionment, but the court said they were direct taxes, and so they were ruled unconstitutional because they were not apportioned - pretty simple really. The ruling did NOT say that income taxes were illegal!

now comes the 16th amendment - one of the shortest amendments:

This removes the requirement to apportion taxes as required by Article 1, Section 9, Clause 4 above. And nothing else!

As a result of Amendment 16 direct taxes can now be levied without need for them to be in proportion to populations. Again it's actually quite simple......unless you are a tax protestor!

A bunch of people have tried to show that the 16th Amendment is not legal, was not properly ratified, etc, but that argument is so hackneyed that it is now considered a frivolous argument by the US courts, and the wiki page on Tax Protester arguments about the 16th does a better job of pointing it out than I can.

The 16th Amendment makes no change to what taxes are levied, nor to whether the US can levy taxes in the first place - which power comes from Article I, Section 8, Clause 1 of the Constitution:

constitution texts above have been taken from www.constitutionus.com

The Rational Wiki page on Tax Protestors has scathing and possibly amusing (depending on your soh!) commentary about arguments including the 16th Amendment one
 

SeriouslyDebatable

Active Member
The ruling did NOT say that income taxes were illegal!

I have an answer to that.

DUH!

Is a direct income tax illegal? No! Is a non apportioned direct income tax STILL legal? NO!
The problem is that the direct income tax is STILL not apportioned.

Apportion means to divide equally among the people. The grace commission audited the IRS and discovered YEARS ago that NOT ONE PENNY of the income tax goes to any service that we expect the government to provide.

Hey mick, for accuracy can you please add another "debunked", to cancel out the "debunked"... or remove "debunked" from the beginning of the title of the thread? Thanks!
 

SeriouslyDebatable

Active Member
This removes the requirement to apportion taxes as required by Article 1, Section 9, Clause 4 above. And nothing else!
Never properly ratified.

http://www.givemeliberty.org/features/taxes/notratified.htm
 

SeriouslyDebatable

Active Member
It is common sense dude.

Hey everybody! I have an idea!!! Who wants to ratify this law to take your money, not give any of it back to you, and let us be unaccountable for how it is spent?

HOW MANY PEOPLE WOULD AGREE TO SUCH A THING? and you really think the 16th was ratified huh? LOL!

Your argument is silly and childlike.
 

MikeC

Closed Account
I have an answer to that.

DUH!

I am sure you think that is actually an answer.

Is a direct income tax illegal? No! Is a non apportioned direct income tax STILL legal? NO!
The problem is that the direct income tax is STILL not apportioned.

no - that was the problem in 1895. It has not been a problem since 1916.

the supposed failure to properly ratify the 16th amendment is so egregiously wrong that it has been declared a frivolous argument by US courts - I gave a link in the OP.

Here's another take on it:

so you are pushing FRAUD - you are proposing and supporting a crime!!

Apportion means to divide equally among the people.

Right up until the 16th amendment.

The grace commission audited the IRS and discovered YEARS ago that NOT ONE PENNY of the income tax goes to any service that we expect the government to provide.

Which has nothing to do with either proportionment or the 16th amendment

Hey mick, for accuracy can you please add another "debunked", to cancel out the "debunked"... or remove "debunked" from the beginning of the title of the thread? Thanks!

Alternatively perhaps ban SD for knowingly and deliberately advocating fraud.
 

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member
SD has informed me via email that he's
Hence I've extended his ban to permanent
 

Gunguy45

Senior Member.
Well....I'm not sure how much authority he has in this regard....and I doubt his influence will make much difference elsewhere. Ah well....they come and they go.....
 
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
Rory Debunked: UK undertaker's claim that Covid vaccine is responsible for spike in deaths Coronavirus COVID-19 0
Marc Powell Debunked: 9/11 truth experts are knowledgeable professionals and their judgments are to be trusted 9/11 195
Marc Powell Debunked: Explosions preparatory to demolition of the WTC North Tower are visible as Flight 175 crashes into the South Tower 9/11 7
Mick West Debunked: Pfizer Developing a Twice-Per-Day COVID Pill, Taken Alongside Vaccines Coronavirus COVID-19 0
Marc Powell Debunked: Demolition “squib” is visible at top of WTC North Tower before Flight 11 crash 9/11 26
Marc Powell Debunked: Construction worker Philip Morelli experienced an explosion in the sub-basement of the North Tower 9/11 0
Marc Powell Debunked: ABC News correspondent George Stephanopoulos reported an explosion in the subway 9/11 1
Marc Powell Debunked: Debris from twin towers was projected upward by explosives 9/11 13
Marc Powell Debunked: Government officials revealed having foreknowledge of Building 7’s collapse 9/11 58
Marc Powell Debunked: NIST computer simulation of Building 7 collapse is inaccurate 9/11 22
Marc Powell Debunked: FEMA reported finding evidence that steel had melted. 9/11 47
Marc Powell Debunked: VP Dick Cheney ordered a standdown of jet fighters on 9/11 9/11 16
Oystein Debunked: Claim that Bobby McIlvaine's injuries ("lacerations") are best explained as result of glass shards and debris from bombs 9/11 22
Marc Powell Debunked: World Trade Center should not have collapsed due to 9/11 fires 9/11 3
Marc Powell Debunked: Firefighter reports of secondary explosions 9/11 3
Marc Powell Debunked: Steel was hurled hundreds of feet by explosives 9/11 4
Marc Powell Debunked: Demolition Explosion Before Collapse of South Tower 9/11 8
Marc Powell Debunked: Explosion in South Tower Lobby 9/11 7
Marc Powell Debunked: Mysterious Explosion Before the Flight 11 Crash 9/11 48
J.d.K Debunked: Marx: "The classes and the races too weak to master the new conditions must give way... They must perish in the revolutionary Holocaust" Quotes Debunked 0
dimebag2 Poll : Which DOD Navy video do you consider debunked ? UFO Videos and Reports from the US Navy 74
Mick West Debunked: Diving Triangle UFO Photos from Reddit [Fake] UFOs and Aliens 37
Theferäl [Debunked] Object Seen From Airplane Above Canberra: 04 Apr 2012 Skydentify - What is that Thing in the Sky? 5
TEEJ Debunked: Claim that Joe Biden's hand passes through microphone during White House press gaggle, 16th March 2021 Election 2020 8
bird_up Debunked: "Interdimensional being" caught on CCTV in Neza, Mexico Ghosts, Monsters, and the Paranormal 6
M Debunked: Atmospheric pressure on Mars is 9 PSI, not 0.09 PSI as claimed by NASA Science and Pseudoscience 75
Patrick Gonzalez Debunked: missing cable on Perseverance landing footage proves it is fake. General Discussion 3
TEEJ Debunked: Biden's Oval Office "Coming Apart at the Seams" [It's a Door] Election 2020 19
derrick06 Debunked: UFO over California Highway (TMZ) UFOs and Aliens 1
P Debunked: 7 Alleged photos of aliens UFOs and Aliens 9
Mick West Debunked: Biden signing "Blank" Executive Orders Election 2020 5
Mick West Debunked: Biden in "Fake" Oval Office Election 2020 27
P Debunked: UN hidden camera: the first UFO contact happened [Deep Fake] UFOs and Aliens 3
Mick West Debunked: 94% of Fulton County Ballots Manually Adjudicated [It's a Process all Batches go Through] Election 2020 0
Mick West Debunked: "Missile Strike" caused Nashville Explosion General Discussion 3
Mick West Debunked: Nashville Explosion was "Across the Street" from the RV General Discussion 0
Mick West Debunked: "Error rate of 68.5% Allowable is .0008%" [Neither is True] Election 2020 4
Mick West Debunked: Claim that the Electoral College Count On Jan 6 will Change the Election Election 2020 136
Rory Debunked: Einstein wrote "blind belief in authority is the greatest enemy of truth" Quotes Debunked 12
Mick West Debunked: Navid Keshavarz-Nia's Claims of "A Sudden Rise in Slope" as Election Fraud Evidence Election 2020 5
Mick West Debunked: Trump's Claim of "1,126,940 votes created out of thin air" in PA Election 2020 9
Mick West Debunked: Crowder's "Fraud Week" Title Graphic (and Why it Matters) Election 2020 1
JFDee Debunked: Democratic senators complained about 'vote switching' by Dominion voting machines in 2019 Election 2020 2
Mendel Debunked: The Democrats are trying to take away freedom of religion Election 2020 6
H Debunked: Dr. Shiva's Scatterplot Analysis of Michigan Precincts Election 2020 43
Mick West Debunked: Suspicious "Biden Only" Ballots in Georgia Election 2020 3
Mick West Debunked: "Nancy Pelosi's long time Chief of Staff is a key executive at Dominion Voting" Election 2020 0
Mick West Debunked: Wisconsin Turnout 89% Impossible High [Actually 72%] Election 2020 1
Mick West Debunked: Video of Poll Worker "Filling In" Ballots. Election 2020 3
Mick West Debunked: Pentagon has Evidence of "Off-World Vehicles Not Made on this Earth" UFO Videos and Reports from the US Navy 14
Related Articles


















































Related Articles

Top