Claims that compass “symbols” are evidence of Masonic involvement

Inti

Senior Member.
I’ve seen a number of claims that historical figures were Freemasons based on the presence of “Masonic symbols” in portraits of them.

For instance. The Flat Earther Eric Dubay claims that

“From Pythagoras to Copernicus, Galileo and Newton, to modern astronauts like Aldrin, Armstrong and Collins, to director of NASA and Grand Commander of the 33rd degree C. Fred Kleinknecht, the founding fathers of the spinning ball mythos have all been Freemasons! “

The text version of this claim is at http://www.atlanteanconspiracy.com/2015/08/200-proofs-earth-is-not-spinning-ball.html,

He makes the same claim in his YouTube video at . At around 108 minutes, but the text version is easier to access. In both case it's his point 191.

I having made a lot of replies in comments, on YouTube and later collected my own point-by point replies at http://roundearthsense.blogspot.co.uk/. You can guess how much the flat earthers have engaged in debate, though.

He supports this with this graphic.




https://www.metabunk.org/data/MetaMirrorCache/afe1e175561c5e1d30190c8075ebaccc.jpg


And this one



https://www.metabunk.org/data/MetaMirrorCache/ef11bdd37b9cdd33b9476dce4b387065.jpg

I'll leave aside the different hand positions, as too weak to be worth debunking.
(Edit) I see the hand sign claim has already been debunked.

https://www.metabunk.org/can-someone-please-debunk-the-masonic-hidden-hand-sign.t1278/#post-32012

The only evidence he offers that all these thinkers were Freemasons is the presence of a pair of compasses, or sometimes a square, in portraits of them.


Now, it's certainly true that Freemasons use the square and compasses as a symbol. That's because actual masons, that is builders in stone, have used these for many centuries as tools in their work.


So did anyone whose work involved measuring and drawing accurately. In fact, that is the meaning of the compasses or setsquare in these pictures: they denote precision and care in measurement. It's a little like the way that many present-day portraits of thinkers include a computer in the picture.


These are standard tools used by builders, architects, map-makers, artists, architects, navigators and many others. Often, they have been used as symbols of those trades, too.


By pure chance, I noticed an example of this while I was thinking about Dubay's claim. I am a volunteer steward in a local museum, and I noticed this map on the wall there.



Here again is the symbol of the compasses marking out the scale on the map, and implying accurate and careful measurement. There's clearly no necessary connection with the Freemasons when you see that.


Later, I noticed these compasses in a display of coopers’ tool for making barrels. Does this imply that barrel makers were freemasons? No, they just needed to measure precisely so that their barrels didn't leak.





And, while I was tidying up the map photo above to post it, I noticed the icon for the tool I used to crop out the surrounding wall:






Yes, it's the square from the square and compasses, as seen beside Pythagoras, Copernicus and Galileo in Dubay's "evidence". Does this mean that this standard symbol in my image editor program is a secret tool of the Freemasons? No, it means that it depicts the tool traditionally used to get right-angles straight. As it does in Dubay's pictures.

Edit: Trailblazer suggests below that this is actually a photographic matte. That's probably true, though I suspect that the shape of the matte was derived from the old square tool. As he says, the point remains valid; it's a functional tool shape not a symbol of freemasonry.

By the way, is Dubay really claiming that Freemasonry existed more than 2500 years ago, at the time of Pythagoras?
 
Last edited:

Trailblazer

Moderator
Staff member
And, while I was tidying up the map photo above to post it, I noticed the icon for the tool I used to crop out the surrounding wall:

...

Yes, it's the square from the square and compasses,
Is it? I thought it was meant to look like a photographic matte:



Not that this is meant to negate your point, by the way!
 

Inti

Senior Member.
Is it? I thought it was meant to look like a photographic matte:



Not that this is meant to negate your point, by the way!
THANKS, AND You may be right, but the matte you show looks very like a square tool. I'd take a large bet that a CT would be happy to claim it as a masonic symbol in the 'right' context
 

Henk001

Senior Member.
By the way, is Dubay really claiming that Freemasonry existed more than 2500 years ago, at the time of Pythagoras?
Apparently he does, and he puts himself thus sidelined for any serious discussion.
He might as well claim that Pythagoras was using CGI images.
 

Inti

Senior Member.
Apparently he does, and he puts himself thus sidelined for any serious discussion.
He might as well claim that Pythagoras was using CGI images.
True, and the earliest videos of earth from orbit which he claims are cgi go back to the mid 1960s, before such cgi tech existed,. In fact I seem to recall that they had to hand animate the computer spaceship displays in the film 2001 A Space Odyssey, released in 1968 because they didn't have the tech to do them for real.
 

Donn

New Member
In my haste to respond early this morning I neglected to cite sources ‍♂ So I’ll repost and do so in accordance to the sites posting guidelines.

I think that today it’s unlikely people encounter squares and compasses, as tools and instruments, very often unless they are students or practice a trade in which they are employed. They don’t realize that these instruments were used regularly across a wide range of disciplines and professions. They have a hard time with the concept of context or possibly think it irrelevant. The association they have made between these objects and what they represent as symbols is incredibly strong and completely overpowers rationality.

They don’t see the square and compasses as common tools which also have a deeper significance to a select few. Instead they become cryptic symbols of a shadowy cabal which are sometimes used by certain trades and disciplines.

As Freemason myself I can confidently state that our symbols are not unique. They consist of tools of the stonemasons trade, elements of architecture, Biblical images etc.

Our symbolism is a product of centuries of change and innovation. They were not passed down from antiquity as a complete system nor are all symbols universal to the fraternity. Jurisdictions can and do vary in what symbols they employ.

https://dr-david-harrison.com/freemasonry/the-lost-symbols-of-freemasonry-introduction/

By having such a broad variety of symbols, including ones lost, forgotten, seldom used, plus countless others affiliated with clandestine and spurious Masonic rites you’d be hard pressed to NOT find images of the objects used as symbols in art! Let alone objects that kinda, sorta resemble Masonic symbols. This is where context is important.

What makes these mundane things Masonic symbols is found in how they are configured and presented. Squares and compasses remain just squares and compasses unless they are observed in a certain conspicuous arrangement. For instance the position of the points either above or below the square indicates one of the three Masonic degrees
153259EA-DF91-4CA1-9E51-F393DA22086E.jpeg

Masonic grips or “secret handshakes” are a mode of recognition. They are not done upon meeting someone new let alone in a highly public setting in front of cameras. Nor are they done on their own. They are accompanied with a specific set of challenge and answer questions, passwords and other modes of identification. This process is done in private, ideally in lodge. Once a brother is confirmed to be such there is no longer a need for them to be examined. Grips are not simply a “Masonic greeting”.

When it’s understood how grips are used and what purpose they serve pictures like this simply make no sense

0C5FEFFD-07F5-46B5-9B18-5A646570A945.gif

Same holds true for images of the notorious Masonic hidden hand. The image most frequently used as evidence that placing ones hand within the breast of ones shirt as rock solid evidence of ones affiliation comes from the exposure called Duncan’s Ritual. (I’m providing a link to a PDF of the exposure not for the purpose of supporting any particular claim but as an item of interest due to its popularity among Masonic conspiracy circles http://freemasonrywatch.org/duncans.masonic.ritual.and.monitor.1866.pdf)

If you read the Royal Arch Degree it becomes clear that the “hidden hand” is not the due guard or sign of a particular degree but of an officer who during the Royal Arch Degree plays the role of Master of the Second Veil. There are 3 Masters of the Veil. The “hidden hand” is associated with the second one.
C558D62A-324A-4A7A-8089-957D3EB25355.jpeg

Using the Royal Arch Degree found in Duncan’s you read that the Masters of the Veils act as guardians ensuring only properly qualified candidates progress on to the “real secrets” of the degree.

Think about that. It’s not a mode of recognition. It’s not the actual due guard or sign of a particular degree. It’s only used to pass from the first Veil onto the third. It’s a steppingstone and not even the final one at that! So why on earth would this be such a popular Masonic symbol?!

D1ACCD87-4437-4938-B818-0181559DBBAC.png
Examining symbols without understanding the context is like trying to read a book with no coherent syntax. It doesn’t make sense. It’s just a jumble of things. You can’t toss random words out in French and claim to be proficient. You must be able to communicate in way others understand.

Masonic symbols communicate certain principles and concepts. These are further expressed in how they are presented and configured.

Examining sources cited and explaining the role and function of these symbols can be enlightening to those who don’t grasp their nuances and intricacies.

If anyone in particular is interested in examining a fantastic piece of scholarly research into Masonic symbols, I wholeheartedly recommend this book

https://www.amazon.com/dp/088053074X/?tag=cowboyprogra-20
 

Steven Ian

Closed Account
I’ve seen a number of claims that historical figures were Freemasons based on the presence of “Masonic symbols” in portraits of them.

For instance. The Flat Earther Eric Dubay claims that

“From Pythagoras to Copernicus, Galileo and Newton, to modern astronauts like Aldrin, Armstrong and Collins, to director of NASA and Grand Commander of the 33rd degree C. Fred Kleinknecht, the founding fathers of the spinning ball mythos have all been Freemasons! “

By the way, is Dubay really claiming that Freemasonry existed more than 2500 years ago, at the time of Pythagoras?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagoras#On_Western_esotericism

Being Scottish myself i do not see what is so bad about the Scottish Rite of Freemasonry that members should be ashamed to be associated?

And what was so bad about Pythagoras, Copernicus, Galileo and Newton, Aldrin, Armstrong, Collins, or Fred Kleinknecht?

They did not worship the Devil or sacrifice children as far as i am aware.
Very accomplished people imo

If the supposed mythological speculative society that exists as a philisophical society in Edinburgh to this day

is anyway connected to the freemasons then the most devilish thing about them is their utilitarian philosophies of enlightenment and reason

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Speculative_Society

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_Enlightenment#Mathematics,_science_and_medicine

Some people believe Science to be Satanic as some consider Science a threat to certain beliefs


Also Freemasonry is modeled at it's roots in Western esotericism and Esoteric Satanism modeled aspects of itself on Western esotericism

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satanism#Religious_Satanism

But Pythagoras as far as i am aware was not a Satanist.
Nothing Satanic about rational enlightenment, except for the fact the Kabbalistic aspects may be considered Paganism by some, and Scientific aspects outright blasphemy.

Therefore, what does it matter if those names mentioned were all Freemasons? it does not make all the accusations pointed at freemasons true in the slightest.


Also, from your post: a Grand Commander of the 33rd degree C "is" the title of a Grand Commander from The Supreme Council for the ancient Scottish Rite
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_Council,_Scottish_Rite_(Southern_Jurisdiction,_USA)

So at least one of the names on your list are high ranking freemason
 
Last edited:

Steven Ian

Closed Account
Regards to the photo of the Pope in a picture above, i would find it incredible to believe the Pope would be a freemason as Canon law condemned the Freemasons.

And the ban was never lifted. Just the words updated.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freemasonry#Christianity_and_Freemasonry[/QUOTE]

Unless of course he has decided to join the very group his Church regard to be Satanists.
 

Trailblazer

Moderator
Staff member
Therefore, what does it matter if those names mentioned were all Freemasons? it does not make all the accusations pointed at freemasons true in the slightest.
My grandfather was a freemason. He died when I was quite young and I never spoke to him about it, but as far as my parents were concerned it was just a silly boys' drinking club, not anything sinister at all.
 
Thread starter Related Articles Forum Replies Date
A Claims of Drug Overdose in the Death of George Floyd Current Events 31
derrick06 5G Health Claims and Theories 5G and Other EMF Health Concerns 16
Dan Wilson Claim:HIV Protein Sequences in Covid-19 (report withdrawn by authors) & other "man made" claims Coronavirus COVID-19 31
Oystein Debunked: AE911T: CNBC Anchor Ron Insana claims Building 7 a Controlled Implosion 9/11 13
W Debunked: Qanon claims there have been 51k sealed indictments filed this year. Current Events 11
Mick West Russian Claims of a "False Flag" Chemical Weapons Attack in Douma, Syria Current Events 10
FlightMuj Claims of Predictions of Chemtrails in Old Texts Contrails and Chemtrails 3
deirdre Debunked: Alex Jones claims kids '[walking around firehouse] with hands up' in Megan Kelly interview Sandy Hook 1
Bill Statler "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence": practical problems using this argument Practical Debunking 3
MikeG Debunked: Mike Adam's Claims Regarding HPV "Shock Study" Health and Quackery 5
Chew Debunked: flat earth claims about lighthouse ranges Flat Earth 8
E Debunked: Virginia Shooting Hoax Claims - Lack of visible shell casings mean fake gun Conspiracy Theories 22
trevor Virginia Shooting Hoax Claims - Can People Run After Being Shot [Yes] Conspiracy Theories 41
Mick West Debunked: MH370: Daily Mail claims new sonar images indicate aircraft debris Flight MH370 3
TEEJ Bellingcat Analysis of Satellite Imagery Used In Russian Claims Against Ukraine Flight MH17 104
Trailblazer Debunked: Look-up.org.uk's claims of aerial spraying over London on April 12 2015 Contrails and Chemtrails 21
Graham2001 'NASA worker' claims to have seen humans walking on Mars in 1979 UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 7
CapnPegleg Debunked: Boyd Bushman, Area 51 scientist, claims existence of aliens in deathbed video [Hoax] Conspiracy Theories 16
Redwood James Fetzer Claims Lenny Pozner Forged Death Certificate Sandy Hook 13
Mick West Debunked: The Science Claims of Global March Against Chemtrails and Geoengineering Contrails and Chemtrails 4
Tobes Article in The Telegraph claims James Foley beheading video staged Conspiracy Theories 108
Dan Wilson Resources for Debunking GMO Toxicity Claims Health and Quackery 1
Mike Fl Debunked: Wolfgang W. Hablig's "Script" Claims Sandy Hook 5
Libertarian Claims Ukranian military using civilian planes as cover Flight MH17 72
Tobes Debunked: James Fetzer claims Shannon Hick's photo is "smoking gun" proof of a drill Sandy Hook 24
Josh Heuer MH17: Russia Claims Ukranian military plane flying nearby before incident Flight MH17 121
CapnPegleg Vegas Police Officers Shot - False Flag claims coming? Conspiracy Theories 32
nanotchi UniversalFreePress claims that " Democrats Plan to Repeal 1st Amendment Conspiracy Theories 8
MikeC Claims of Russia rigging the Crimean referendum General Discussion 11
Tobes Debunked: Movie producer Nathan Folks claims bombing false flag, Voice of Russia says blood too red Boston Marathon Bombings 134
Redwood James Fetzer Claims Robbie Parker Is Actor Sandy Hook 40
zebra100 Businessman Claims he Saw ‘White Plane Image’ Under Water while Flying from Melbourn Flight MH370 0
vooke Debunked: Tim Ackers MH370 Debris Claims Flight MH370 15
Tobes Debunked: Dr. Stanley Monteith's claims about Jeff Bauman's injuries Boston Marathon Bombings 12
S RT claims BBC stages Syria chemical attack to propagate war. [BBC Responds] Conspiracy Theories 49
derwoodii Flight MH370: Oil Rig Worker Mike McKay claims to spot plane crashing near Vietnam Flight MH370 50
nanotchi Debunked: Iran claims Snowden Documents Proving “US-Alien-Hitler” Link Stun Russia [Sorcha Faal] UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 2
gerrycan AE911 Letter to Inspector General Claims NIST WTC7 Report is Provably False 9/11 161
Jay Reynolds Debunked: Look-up.org.uk claims to find Gulf of Guinea Chemtrails base Contrails and Chemtrails 13
deirdre Conspiracy Theorist Mark S. Mann claims of being a Ct. Police Officer and Firearms Industry Executiv Sandy Hook 4
John Smith Kevin Ryan's Claims about UL certifying steel components for the WTC 9/11 32
moderateGOP Poking holes in "Syrian Rebels" Claims about Chemical Weapons Use General Discussion 137
Mick West Statement from Michael Mulder of Aerotoxic.org regard claims by Max Bliss Contrails and Chemtrails 1
Jay Reynolds Debunked: Dane Wigington's Claims That UV is "Off The Charts" Contrails and Chemtrails 207
Rroval Man Claims Mars Space Station Discovered On Google Mars (VIDEO, POLL) UFOs, Aliens, Monsters, and the Paranormal 2
somnamblst Posting this in light of the "EMT" claims regarding Jeff Bauman Boston Marathon Bombings 6
HappyMonday 9/11 Claims 9/11 6
Boston GMO's myths and truths. Heavily noted review of the claims of the GMO giants General Discussion 191
chem_what Any debunkings of these ridiculous claims? Contrails and Chemtrails 2
rezn8d Aquiess & Sciblue Inc - Dubious claims about rainmaking technology General Discussion 100
Related Articles


















































Related Articles

Top