Analysis: Crathes Castle "Ghost" in Doorway Photo

Mick West

Administrator
Staff member

Crathes Castle Scotland Ghost Photo Montage.jpg


Supposed ghost photos have a number of possible explanations. The two most likely are that it's a photo of something that just kind of looks like a "ghost", or that it's some kind of hoax photo. Or course there's also the distant possibility that maybe it's a ghost, but since that would require an entirely new scientific understanding of the universe and is something that has never been definitively observed before in all of human history then it's generally a good idea to eliminate the other two first. While this not the most important form of debunking, ghost photos are also an interesting exercise in figuring things out with Google and Photoshop.

So, what have we here?
Bill Andrew, 78, was taking a picture of his family in front of the castle when they noticed what look like a ghostly apparition in one of its doorways.
...
He took the picture of his family in front of the castle but it was only afterwards that Coleen spotted the strange figure in a doorway in the background.
...
Coleen contacted staff to see if there was an explanation for the ghostly sighting as the door was closed.
Content from External Source
First of all let's look at some other photos of the scene. I searched Google Images for "Crathes castle", and set the minimum image size to 10MP to ensure we get detailed photos.
20161129-080956-ibfg8.jpg

This led me to this photo of the castle:
20161129-081119-cdzb7.jpg

Notice two things here, the door seems taller from this viewpoint, and the there's two shadowy figures in it!

Of course the shadowy figures here are just visitors, which we can see if we brighten the image a bit:20161129-081446-sz4jc.jpg

Now the "ghost" looks rather odd as it seems to have a full height cape, which would be rather old-fashioned. But we can see from this photo that the legs of the figure have been cut off. If we scale the and position the "ghost" image, we can see it matches a normal sized figure in the doorway, wearing a normal white coat.
20161129-081954-c1pf1.jpg

Add some legs and you've just got a tall figure wearing a coat. Maybe a light colored raincoat with a hood.

20161129-103614-1eior.jpg

Here's another photo of the castle:
20161129-083340-4dy55.jpg

Again with the shadowy figure or a regular castle visitor in the doorway:
20161129-083411-49xyi.jpg

So shadowy figures in the doorway are nothing new.

Notice also here how the open door roughly matches the lighting in the "ghost" photo. With the door actually closed you see the lighter reddish brown wood. Hard to say though with the limited resolution and lighting, and the door could well be closed.
20161129-084355-ya4ny.jpg

So it would seem that the simplest explanation here is that it's someone stood in the open doorway. Of course it could also be a fake photo - it's pretty easy to add a "ghost". But I think I'd put that second on the list. Still incredibly higher than an actual ghost though.
 

Attachments

  • 20161129-084132-yr641.jpg
    20161129-084132-yr641.jpg
    98.3 KB · Views: 417
Last edited:

Trailblazer

Moderator
Staff member
Here's a photo from a similar viewpoint (but further to the left), with the lawn obscuring the bottom part of the doorway, and the visitors' legs.

upload_2016-11-29_17-16-20.png

Cropped from https://flic.kr/p/LrMPRq


And another, from just a few weeks ago, showing the door open and visitors who look as if they have just emerged from inside:

upload_2016-11-29_17-20-6.png

https://flic.kr/p/NGtY16


Also from October:

upload_2016-11-29_17-21-33.png

https://flic.kr/p/NktGfW


In fact from a quick search it seems that there are more photos with visitors in that doorway than without!
 
Last edited:
Top