Tags:
  1. Mick West

    Mick West Administrator Staff Member

    Tremblor3.05L.

    I saw the above image shared on Facebook with the description: 'Death Valley is coming to life as a direct result of the rains caused by El Niño. Called a "superbloom".'

    The problem is it's not Death Valley, and it's not this year. It's actually from 11 years ago, and was taken in the Tremblor Range in California (170 miles from Death Valley) in march 2005 by Frank Kee.

    Even back in 2008 the image had been widely and misleadingly shared on the internet, as the photographer himself describes:
    https://web.archive.org/web/20080613124558/http://www.keesphotos.com/gallery/1680669_gmPVN
    Now this is a pretty harmless example of bunk (except for Mr Kee not getting due credit). But it's a great illustration of why we should not trust the labeling of images on the internet. I had immediate suspicions on seeing the image, so did a quick image search, and one of the first things that came up was a story about desert blooms in Chile:

    20160229-104824-24pch.

    There were even multiple instances of this image being used to illustrate the story of the bloom in the Atacama desert, so it seemed like case closed at that point.
    http://www.telesurtv.net/english/mu...m-in-Chiles-Atacama-Desert-20151102-0017.html
    20160229-105340-q5mc8.

    I was about to point out (on Facebook) where the image had come from, but when I clicked on the Twitter link the post was missing. So I searched a little further, and found hundreds more usages of the image, many predating this tweet and the 2015 story about Atacama.

    It then became obvious that this was a very old image (in internet terms), and one that had been shared so many times its origin might be hard to find. Reverse image searches just turned up hundreds more examples, and the oldest one on Tineye.com was only 2008.

    So instead of searching by image, I searched with a few search terms to see what came up "Desert Bloom", "Death valley flowers bloom", etc. Finally got a result with "Desert wildflowers"
    20160229-105942-z6wfm.
    The first image result led to a 2009 forum post:
    http://www.desertusa.com/mb3/viewtopic.php?t=1398
    The first link changes with time, but a bit of digging in Archive.org (looking at the page around March 2005), and we find the original:
    https://web.archive.org/web/20050415005411/http://www.desertusa.com/wildflo/ca.html
    20160229-110729-nq7jd.


    So the lesson here in tracking down a suspicious image is not to stop when you find what looks like the real source. Apply the same skepticism you did to the original source, and check to see if that claim actually holds up. A quick and necessary test is to see if the image existed at an earlier date. In this case the story about the desert blooms in Chile looked authoritative, even crediting a photographer (not Mr Kee though). However the story was from 2015, and there were hundreds of usages of the photo from earlier years.

    And don't just rely on image searches. Keyword search can return results that are more relevant. Sometimes you've just got to keep digging until something crops up.

    The GPS checks out too.
    20160229-112353-oz3e8.
     
    Last edited: Feb 29, 2016
    • Like Like x 11
    • Winner Winner x 1
  2. Mick West

    Mick West Administrator Staff Member

    This particular image is so old it was briefly debunked ten years ago, in 2006, when there were already a variety of different stories about it.
    https://www.truthorfiction.com/wildflowers/
    There was actually a link to TruthorFiction in the desertusa.com forum post, but unfortunately they had changed their URL format so the link was broken.

    It was also covered on Snopes:
    http://www.snopes.com/photos/natural/flowers.asp
    The "Status: True" is a bit unfortunate though, as one might be tempted to quickly assume that the new Facebook claim checks out. They also repeat the location as "East of Tehachapi", which is flat wrong, as it's 70 miles West of Tehachapi - almost none of the description in the example is correct, so a bit of a poor job by Snopes there.
     
    Last edited: Feb 29, 2016
  3. Gridlock

    Gridlock Active Member

    I took a whirl through Google to see if I could trace it back using some of their advanced tools, but no cigar.

    Interestingly though this image appears on the first page of results for [scottish countryside] and [iranian landscape] and presumably a multitude of others. It's really done the rounds.
     
  4. Mick West

    Mick West Administrator Staff Member

    • Like Like x 2
  5. Trailspotter

    Trailspotter Senior Member

    A non-natural purple sky in the OP image hints on its colours being modified or enhanced. Nevertheless, these and other images found by searching flickr for 'mojave desert wildflowers' confirm that the desert in April can be very colourful indeed:


     
  6. deirdre

    deirdre Moderator Staff Member

    it is enhanced. http://www.keesphotos.com/
    upload_2016-3-1_17-20-29.

    his exif data is in the photo.
     
  7. M Bornong

    M Bornong Senior Member

    It is quite the sight to see. The first 2, I took on April 20, 2014 near Lancaster CA, along Hwy. 138, near the California Poppy Reserve. The second 2, March 15, 2013 along Hwy 223 near Arvin CA. It doesn't happen every year, the timing of the rain and warming of Spring have to be just right. The bloom has been decent this year, possibly the rain predicted this weekend will push it over the top.

    DSCF0078.JPG DSCF0086.JPG DSCF8695. DSCF8708.

    "Not orange, not gold, but if pure gold were liquid and could raise a cream, that golden cream might be like the color of the poppies." John Steinbeck
     
    Last edited: Mar 1, 2016
    • Like Like x 5
  8. Landru

    Landru Moderator Staff Member

    Those are California Poppys which is the state flower of California.
     
  9. Marin B

    Marin B Active Member

    • Agree Agree x 1
  10. M Bornong

    M Bornong Senior Member

    This site keeps up pretty well.

    If you want to chase the valley in the OP, this is today's report.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  11. Mick West

    Mick West Administrator Staff Member

    That's the site the photo in question was first posted on. They do indeed seem to keep up pretty well.
     
  12. trevor

    trevor Active Member

    looks like the weather there is mid 70's, sunny, and 100% chance of Allergy attacks.
     
  13. M Bornong

    M Bornong Senior Member

    Last edited: Mar 2, 2016
  14. trevor

    trevor Active Member

  15. Cony

    Cony New Member

    I was testing Google Image to identify photos and it suggested that the famous 2005 Frank Kee picture from Carrizo Plains, was in China :p