1. Antithesis

    Antithesis New Member

    This popular Joe Rogan video shows a lunar flag wave as an astronaut crosses the screen. Loop of the segment in question:

    [​IMG]

    The key observation is that the flag begins to move before the astronaut crosses in front:

    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]

    If the flag's movement were the result of an air current caused by an astronaut actor in an earth-based studio, then the flag wouldn't move before the astronaut reaches it.

    The flag's behavior is that of static electrical repulsion. The flag is repulsed by the astronaut.

    Dragging your feet across a shaggy carpet results in a buildup of static electrical charge, called triboelectric charge. It works best when the air is dry because dry air is a better insulator than humid air. An even better insulator is no air, and an even better shaggy carpet is the surface of the moon:
    But in order for the flag to be repulsed by the astronaut, the flag would have to be charged, too. So how did the flag become charged? To address that question, let us begin with this 40-second demonstration (10:40 to 11:20):


    Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1-SibwIPM4#t=10m40s

    1. He rubs the glass rod, generating an electric charge on the rod.
    2. He repeatedly touches the balloon, transferring charge to the balloon.
    3. He rubs the glass rod again, charging the rod again.
    4. The balloon is repelled by the rod.

    Compare this to the full video of the astronauts:


    Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymwE1sNm82Y

    1. An astronaut shuffles around while holding a flag, building up a charge. This is like rubbing the rod in the rod/balloon demonstration.

    2. The astronaut plants the flag, which is now charged because it came from the charged astronaut. This is like the rod transferring charge to the balloon.

    3. An off-screen astronaut to the left has been shuffling around. This is like charging the rod again.

    4. The off-screen astronaut comes into view and crosses in front of the flag. The flag is repelled by the astronaut, just as the balloon is repelled by the rod.
     
    Last edited: Sep 19, 2019
    • Like Like x 3
    • Agree Agree x 2