European Union -vs- Monsanto

It has been mentioned in this thread

https://www.metabunk.org/threads/16...-noted-review-of-the-claims-of-the-GMO-giants

It relates to a press release by USDA on the 29th May in which some Round Up resistant Wheat plants were found in a field in Oregon

http://www.aphis.usda.gov/newsroom/2013/05/ge_wheat_detection.shtml

There is a useful Q&A

http://www.aphis.usda.gov/publications/biotechnology/2013/faq_brs_ge_wheat_detection.pdf

Essentially Monsanto have done no trials on Oregon since 2001, and worldwide there are no commercially available wheat. A farmer has found some GMO plants in their field, reported it and now it is been looked into
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I know many people on here champion U.S GMO's and that the U.S Gov has pulled every trick in the book to get GMO's accepted in Europe but basically 'we won' :), so it appears that Monsanto have basically given up in Europe (apart from Spain, Portugal and some former Eastern European countries), so there will be more for the U.S population to eat (without even knowing as there is no labeling), so for those Americans who do not want it, seems you will have to kick up more of a fuss to get rid of it. I wish you 'more power to your elbow'.

They were rejected after being tested but TPTB want to downplay it because "trial results would have an economically harmful effect on the company, despite the fact that the crops did not pass the trial.".

http://www.ir-d.dk/gmo-lose-europe-victory-for-environmental-organisations/
Monsanto will halt production of genetically modified corn in all of Europe, except Spain, Portugal and Czech republic. The agribusiness multinational states not to spend any more money on trials, development, marketing, court cases or anything else to get GM corn accepted in Europe.

.....Two years later, in January 2011, Monsanto expanded these two years of examination with an additional year of testing, which was accepted by the Danish Environmental authority, Miljøstyrelsen.

The procedure is that crop companies’ new crops will be tested by the authority for two years before possibly being allowed for selling and growing in Denmark. At the time, Monsanto wanted to test a total of five different varieties with the transformation NK603.

Trial results are normally open to the public. In this case Monsanto explicitly asked to keep the test silent, and they withdrew the varities before the testing finished, so no results were published.

No information has then been released on these trials.

Authorities support Monsanto on silence

The authorities have – after more than two months consideration – decided to follow Monsanto’s wish to keep the trial results silent.

Key documents in the FOI-case.
The main argument is that publication of the trial results would have an economically harmful effect on the company, despite the fact that the crops did not pass the trial.

Investigative Reporting and Åbenhedstinget together raise the case for The Danish Ministry of Agriculture. From a scientific viewpoint and for the use in other countries it is necessary to also get results of failed trials published, argue the two organisations.

“It is corrupting to the scientific method itself, when companies can decide that only positive results can be published. Therefore it is important to have this research published,” stresses Klaus Sall.
Content from External Source
 
OT, but this whole thing between Monsato and EU or US kind of reminds me of Big Tobacco in the late 70's and 80's, where reports were falsified to hide the facts that cigarettes cause cancer. I'm not saying GMO's cause cancer or even have adverse side effects on humans or crops because there isn't enough science to declare which side is right. I couldn't believe Monsato earned 56 or 59 billion in 2013, its amazing how much money these fertilizer and chemical herbicide companies generate each year.
 
I know many people on here champion U.S GMO's and that the U.S Gov has pulled every trick in the book to get GMO's accepted in Europe but basically 'we won' :), so it appears that Monsanto have basically given up in Europe (apart from Spain, Portugal and some former Eastern European countries), so there will be more for the U.S population to eat (without even knowing as there is no labeling), so for those Americans who do not want it, seems you will have to kick up more of a fuss to get rid of it. I wish you 'more power to your elbow'.

They were rejected after being tested but TPTB want to downplay it because "trial results would have an economically harmful effect on the company, despite the fact that the crops did not pass the trial.".

http://www.ir-d.dk/gmo-lose-europe-victory-for-environmental-organisations/
Monsanto will halt production of genetically modified corn in all of Europe, except Spain, Portugal and Czech republic. The agribusiness multinational states not to spend any more money on trials, development, marketing, court cases or anything else to get GM corn accepted in Europe.

.....Two years later, in January 2011, Monsanto expanded these two years of examination with an additional year of testing, which was accepted by the Danish Environmental authority, Miljøstyrelsen.

The procedure is that crop companies’ new crops will be tested by the authority for two years before possibly being allowed for selling and growing in Denmark. At the time, Monsanto wanted to test a total of five different varieties with the transformation NK603.

Trial results are normally open to the public. In this case Monsanto explicitly asked to keep the test silent, and they withdrew the varities before the testing finished, so no results were published.

No information has then been released on these trials.

Authorities support Monsanto on silence

The authorities have – after more than two months consideration – decided to follow Monsanto’s wish to keep the trial results silent.

Key documents in the FOI-case.
The main argument is that publication of the trial results would have an economically harmful effect on the company, despite the fact that the crops did not pass the trial.

Investigative Reporting and Åbenhedstinget together raise the case for The Danish Ministry of Agriculture. From a scientific viewpoint and for the use in other countries it is necessary to also get results of failed trials published, argue the two organisations.

“It is corrupting to the scientific method itself, when companies can decide that only positive results can be published. Therefore it is important to have this research published,” stresses Klaus Sall.
Content from External Source

Are you talking about Monsanto or GM in general? If GM in general the UK at least is certainly not GM free with a great deal of public funded research.
 
OT, but this whole thing between Monsato and EU or US kind of reminds me of Big Tobacco in the late 70's and 80's, where reports were falsified to hide the facts that cigarettes cause cancer. I'm not saying GMO's cause cancer or even have adverse side effects on humans or crops because there isn't enough science to declare which side is right.

That's really not the case here, so I don't think it's a valid comparison.

http://www.aaas.org/sites/default/files/AAAS_GM_statement.pdf
 
Are you talking about Monsanto or GM in general? If GM in general the UK at least is certainly not GM free with a great deal of public funded research.
Do you have any details on that? It appears from this article that there are none in the U.K for 2014. Seems like GMO has got the boot. Resistance is fertile. :).


Though GM wheat and potatoes have been trialed in the UK in recent years, 2014 will mark the first year that no GMO trials will occur in places like Norfolk and Cambridgeshire. The director of GM Freeze, Helene Paul says, “We’re celebrating a GM-free 2014 in UK fields – long may it continue. We congratulate the millions of UK farmers and shoppers standing up for what is right for their businesses and families, and we’re standing right beside them.” This will be the first year since 2007 that no trials will be conducted and that none are expected.
According to the UK government “Defra currently has no [GM trial] applications under consideration.” As more people in the UK, including farmers and consumers rally to tell their government that they aren’t interested in GM foods, the mega-giants of the food industry have started to finally pay attention. GMO trials have come to a halt in numerous countries throughout Europe. Trials in France, Poland, Italy, and elsewhere have been completely stopped. This includes transgenic GMO trees recently planted in Saint-Cyr-en-Val, near Orléans that were recently destroyed due to activist insistence.
Content from External Source

Read more: http://naturalsociety.com/gmo-failure-uk-first-gmo-trial-free-year-2014/#ixzz32X88at5q
Follow us: @naturalsociety on Twitter | NaturalSociety on Facebook
 
Last edited:
I agree this is bad for science, negative results are as useful as positive ones and should not be hidden.
Lol... I agreed with you Pete.... then I took it back because I thought I can't be seen agreeing with you, agreeing with me; when obviously that just means I agree with myself... so I liked your post instead :)
 
Back
Top